What's new

Long-Term  I fell into a comfortable relationship and now I don't know if/how to get out

ChrisVirtue

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Apr 6, 2019
Messages
118
I need some advice and I don't know where to turn so thought I might as well give this forum a shot.

You can review some of my posting history to get a vibe on me. I leveled up in the game community quite a bit working with a good chunk of RSD coaches. I had a nice foundation of a field report thread on the RSDNation forum, which was shutdown by Owen, and looking back kind of pisses me off since I had so many field reports and lay reports written and I would've just loved to save that thread history for my own review. Enjoying the memories, and also remembering where I came from and what I went through. One of the main reasons I started that field report thread was to have something I could look back on when I am 80...

I think this is the only forum I'm found that is still active with solid advice and perspectives coming from @Chase and others. If there are better forums then let me know. I know most PUA discussion moved to fb groups, and now telegram/discords... but I think that the forum approach is much better due to the long form thought-out nature of posts... I miss the golden age of forums and there is something nostalgic/meaningful about them to me. So I'm grateful that skilledseducer.com exists at least.

Anyways, perhaps that is a bit of a scarcity mindset, and that maybe this is a good thing since it can inspire me to recreate my progress from scratch. Still it is confusing for me at times because I had been counting my lays with that field report, and now I honestly can't tell you how many girls I've hooked up with.

I've had some good winning streaks with several girls in various cold approach "romps" as I would call them. Things like 7 girls in 12 days, or 5 girls in 4 days. Overall my lay count by my best estimates is somewhere in the 150-250 range.

This probably sounds dumb but I'm honestly so hazy about the number, and I can't remember hooking up with at least 50% of the girls, which is kind of a shame, as I think having the journal records for myself is useful. Thankfully I have a few lay reports saved locally, and those all have pictures on them as well

I ended up reading through those over the last few days, and it has been sparking something within me... reminding me of who I used to be and how excited pick up would make me. I started listening to the Mystery Method on audible (a classic book that I always felt I was "too good" to read, well I'm more humble now!) and in the early parts of the book he says how cold approach gives a high like no other. I think this is why I always found it addictive. It made me feel alive.

Now, I've learned over the years that chasing the past is not a good idea. I'm not trying to reclaim my old feelings. The PUA community is not the same nowadays, since post-covid I think a lot has changed.

I'm grateful that I got to experience the PUA community. And I'm excited for the next chapter of my life, whatever communities may it hold. I've always thought that the greatest rewards possible for a PUA were as a veiled PUA. For instance, befriending celebrities and models, without ever bringing up a single word of "game". So perhaps that is the way forward for me.

--------

Anyways, I just wanted to give some context of my experience and where my head is at. Now for my current situation:

I'm now in my early 30s and I'm very confused about what to do. In a lot of ways I think I'm just rationalizing my behavior and desire for comfort. I'm someone who even before finding out about game made a decision that "if I feel discomfort then I HAVE to do it". I started facing my fears, and approaching girls was just one of those fears.

I'm currently in a committed monogamous relationship. I already know I'm going to get hated for some of the things I'm about to say...

Here's how it all started:

I had been grinding my PUA journey religiously, and progressing with ups and downs. However I had an underlying sense that something was missing. COVID was very challenging for me... in that, I wanted to keep approaching and pursuing game. Man I tried my hardest but certain sparks were missing. I had to bust my ass just to get in a few approaches, and really go out of my way even in a great game city like Vegas. Before COVID it wasn't like this... To top this all off, RSD kinda pussed out on cold approach content. They scrubbed their youtube of videos that I found immensely valuable. I wish I could download some of the free tour panels in particular, as I had access to some on a MEGA link, but then that MEGA got deleted.

I know that I was missing something, and for whatever reason I started to gravitate to a more "serial monogamy" kind of mindset. I had never been very good at managing legit rotations. And, I kind of just started seeing how long I could keep a relationship going. However, most of the time since I was traveling so much, my go-to was flying girls to visit me... after doing this several times, I know it has pros and cons.

Living in Vegas kinda sucks... and that's part of the issue. I should have moved to LA or Miami sooner. Vegas is more of a spot to practice game for a few months at max. You need to have a homebase city outside vegas and then use Vegas as a secondary city. This is very powerful especially if your homebase city is LA.

So, I would fly girls out that I had gamed while traveling, and kinda just lean on them for emotional support. I liked the feminine energy. I suppose I've always struggled to have a work-game balance. I feel like I could hang with girls or be on the phone with a girl for hours and hours, and let everything else in my life collapse. I use relationships as escapism, and have always had bad boundaries.

So, I had one short relationship that lasted about a month. And then a few months later I had another girl, let's call her G, I had hooked up with that I wanted to fly out. At the time I just thought "I like this girl, of course I want to see her again" and since she lived in a different city, flying her out was the way to do that. Following that trip, I had made some future projections about visiting her, which over the following 2 months, she started to drill me being like "you're never going to come see me, are you?" etc, even though I intended to see her, I was just very caught up with business stuff. In fact, I got very sucked into business and stock trading during this time, basically giving up game completely to just focus all on business and stock-trading.

I was addicted to stock trading, and had made a lot of money due to some insane initial luck, that I slowly but surely lost over the coming year. During this time period I did visit her for about a month (it isn't lost on me that this is a long period of time to visit someone). At the time I thought I was "so cool" for gaming a girl to let me stay at her place for so long... kinda like Ashton Klutcher in the movie "Spread". Due to the stock-trading addiction, it fried my dopamine system quite a bit.. and for a time made it hard for me to do basic life actions (and this basically would come and go over the last 2 years, depending on how addicted I was.)

When I visited her, she told me that she loved me after a few weeks, which I wasn't ready to say back. I must admit at this time I was very confused about love and what it means (being from a PUA background, I understand pair-bonding vs the societal narrative of "one true love").

I'm still confused about love and what it means exactly. We then stuck together since that trip, with her visiting me numerous times over a year until we eventually moved in with each other in a 2 bedroom apartment, where we split the rent. Before moving in, the relationship had progressed as she demanded monogamy from me, which I relented, as I was very vulnerable due to my stock trading addiction, and had basically been relying on her for 100% of my emotional support. Months later, I started to reground myself, and find other forms of support, but still leaning on her from time to time.

Even before moving in with her I was hesitant. I am pretty introverted and having someone in my day-to-day living space can cause me a lot of anxiety/annoyance. As I am really organized and basically OCD with having my living areas perfectly optimized towards my goals.

From my recent FR journal on this site:

"I'm sacrificing personal space as a challenge to see if I can hold my frame and integrate my day-to-day life while being around women. One of my desires is to live in a mansion with 3-5 girls living with me, so I view this as a learning experience for that future scenario.

the PUA lifestyle I live is very different compared to the person I present on my social media. It is very odd to spend 4-5 nights a week cold approaching for hours. I'm trying to find a way to integrate this girl into that lifestyle so that I can have more threesomes."

So, I think part of moving in together, was me again trying to challenge myself in this way... I was thinking that the next level to my game was to become completely aligned and confident in my lifestyle... having girls around 24/7 would basically force nonstop congruence tests UNTIL I become fully congruent and more grounded in my desires and who I am/want to be.

And, I would say that having a LTR did accomplish this. Im not sure if it was the best progression in my game... but it's good to know that my initial goals did get accomplished to some degree... (although maybe this is me just rationalizing getting into a relationship lmao).

However, having the LTR came at a huge sacrifice in that I naturally fell victim to comfort thinking... letting my physical fitness and social skills degrade.

Moving in kinda started off on a bad foot, as the processing of combining possessions like that is fairly annoying and inefficient. I spent easily 100+ hours just slowly trying to get G to change her organizational habits, as she is the type of person who just leaves clutter everywhere and doesn't want to sort through and organize things. (probably learning here that I need a super organized type A girl for a relationship lol - which I know there are a lot of them out there)

Living together in a lot of ways just allowed her to whip me more and more. I gave up photography, as she didn't want me with other girls. I stopped going out or socializing all together, as I didn't really have friends or any reason to.

I admittedly was singularly focused on money, and trying to make enough so that I had that area of my life handled, just as I had the girls area of my life handled by achieving a decent level of mastery in PUA.

I kept telling myself "I'll just keep dating her until my money is handled, because her support is useful and I don't have the time to go out really". I think this is a selfish reason to have a relationship... but in some regard it made sense. But, I also know if I was single, I'd be socializing more which would also be better for my mental health, motivation, etc. Having a gf is draining a lot of the time.

I had ups and downs with money, and our relationship grew more and more distant, although I think it is more of a one-sided distance. I feel distant from her, while she is still loving and attached. I feel pretty much 0 sex drive with her, and no interest in having sex, even though she is just as attractive as when I met her. One thing that concerned me is that I would try to be vulnerable with her, and she would sometimes get triggered into a lot of anger, saying very hurtful things. I've told her numerous times that this makes my love for her weaken... but she doesn't seem to understand that, and has said that "fights happen and it's not a big deal, get over it".

To me it's very confusing to be so vulnerable with someone and for them to say such hurtful things... it makes all of G's support feel like false support that I can't truly rely on. I'm not sure if it makes sense or not to rely on a girl for support anymore... maybe a rotation of girls, but not a single girl as a support system, since it's a conflict of interest with the romantic side of the relationship.

We did eventually move out of the apartment, and she was staying in airbnbs + with her parents while I have had to be out of town for a work contract for the last 2 months.

So, first off, thank god we moved out. Because breaking up while living together would SUCK ASS. Having to deal with the lease etc.

So, I have a bit of freedom right now, which is nice in comparison to the trapped feelings I felt when we shared the apt. Still we are "together" right now.

Right before I left for the work trip, we had a fight because she was asking "why don't you say you love me anymore?" And I just opened up to her, that I haven't really been feeling much love to her, and that our connection has been weakening. I did mention that every time she yells at me, it weakens our bond. I still feel a bond to her, but it's much more like a father/daughter bond or love.... and reminds me of what Esther Vilar says in "the polygamous sex" which my gut tells me is an accurate model for men's desires/tendencies.

And now, we've still been texting everyday and calling most days.

Fortunately, I do feel like just in the last couple weeks I've had a few things align in terms of productivity that I just feel in a much more competent place.

In terms of money, I now have a consistent business income. it isn't massive, but it's more than enough to keep me living comfortable, pay off credit card debt over time, and I have a clear path towards scaling. I also have some other business stuff I'm working on that ties into some passions of mine in a low risk way. Everything business-wise just seems more accessible now that I'm in my 30s, like I just have a better vantage point on how business works.

However, on the other side, I'm scared to leave the relationship for a few reasons.

1. First off, I haven't done a legit approach in a while. I'm considering just doing some tonight to see how it feels. I know that once I get past the first few approaches, most of my game skills will come rushing back to me in a more refined state. One part of me KNOWS that I have the potential to have the strongest game I've ever had if I just simply take my learnings from this LTR and carry it forward.

I'm not sure where I read this, but somewhere was saying that LTRs are the best thing you can do for your game longterm anyways... I'm excited to see if this is true, or just rationalization.

2. Second of all, part of the reason I "allowed" a relationship to happen is because I was started to get scared of improper PUA. A guy I know got charged with sexual assault, and I had an odd lay report where the girl was completely down but then he friends were freaking out and yelling at me for hooking up with her. It was 1000% consensual. I even got consent, but it still triggered some trauma/worry in me... The solution to this would obviously be to dial in my game and make sure to make the girls chase before hooking up, and be conscious of my status/value positioning. IE: running a strict quality level of game and never getting lazy with my game.

3. Third, G is extremely loyal, and it's mostly a personality quality. I wonder that if I wanted another LTR how easy it would be to find a girl this loyal, or if I'm overthinking it and with good enough game I can get loyal LTRs easily if I wanted. She is loving as well, but has times of aloofness and anger too, so not 100% loving, while we were living together there were many fights, where I had to spend 4-8 hours talking to her, to figure out common ground. This actually taught me a lot about communication and conflict resolution... but overall my boundaries were not strong enough. A lot of our fights ended in me appeasing her or stopping the behavior that she didn't like me doing... So yeah I basically was getting whipped.

See, part of me feels like as a man in my 30s, I shouldn't be in a relationship, that it's not allowing me to prioritize my mission and my businesses. Marrying this girl and settling down with kids would just feel like such a bitch move. And to top it off, I just really miss having sex with new girls. I miss the chase of PUA. And, I have so much potential to fuck so many super hot girls due to my understanding of game and psychology... even with just doing photography, whether that's model or onlyfans photography.

Another separate challenge is I don't know if nude/onlyfans photography is something I can do, since over the last year of relationship I started to understand how bad porn is affecting young men, and I'm not sure if I can contribute to that and still feel good about myself... that's a whole separate topic that deserves a post of it's own... so maybe I'll post that in the general thread later on !

Overall though, I think that's the cognitive dissonance as well... on one side I feel like I should embody good values and have a girlfriend and be a good traditional society "role model", please my parents, etc. On the other side I know I just love fucking new girls. I love PUA. And that will never go aware. I think of hugh hefner at age 80 having a smile on his face as he tells you how hot his 2 girlfriends are. I feel like as a man it's one of the most joyous and integral parts of my life, and all the positive experiences I can give to so many other girls out there..

But yeah.... idk

I feel like breaking up with her is the best decision for me. But, with having low boundaries, it's difficult for me to break up with any girl. I'm like super avoidant and non-confrontational... it's something I'm scared to even talk about... However, in business I'm able to have boundaries and walk away from money all the time if it's not a good fit. Maybe I have more abundance with money.

With love/LTR, maybe I'm just in scarcity ? I've almost just been waiting for her to break up with me... and hoping she does... but at the same time if she did try to break up with me, I'd probably fight for the relationship... maybe this is codependence ? Or ego preservation... pair bonding preservation drive ?

I feel like the answer may be the same feelings I felt as when I quit my corporate job to pursue online business.... a lot of my mind was telling me I was making a terrible decision... but my gut knew within that discomfort was the greatest growth possible for my life... and what followed was 4 years of a seriously epic PUA journey ! And I would not be anywhere close to the man I am today, without quitting that soul-sucking 9-5

And now, I sit here... ~3 years after that PUA journey ended and I drifted into this relationship... which also feels like it has drained a lot of my soul and passion from my life.

3 whole years.... and I learned a ton about LTRs and communication and business and managing my stock trading addiction and cutting out porn as well, as when I was into PUA I never had an issue with porn... once in a committed relationship though, it became too tempting... definitely messed me up a bit, but I think it was good for me to see how a man could get sucked into porn. And what so many men are facing who are stuck in marriages they despise.

But yeah at the same time, I've read @Chase 's article on "how to break up" several times... and I know it says to first present it as a break, to revisit in 30 days... but I have no confidence in my ability to break up and hold myself to it. In a lot of ways I've started to understand why abused women stay with their abusers.... a relationship can create a codependent bond that creates this emotional "haze" of not seeing how I can be without them... even though logically that I 100% can and would 99% be going to the gym more, working harder on business and creating more value for the world without her.

I suppose us being away for 2 months has given her a head start on the de-bonding process as @Skills referenced in this post: https://www.skilledseducer.com/thre...e-pair-bond-rush-from-pure-evil-repost.26831/

But yeah... it's just odd to me that it's so hard to break up. I think the finality of it is what is hard. I have no interest in sex with my girlfriend nowadays, but I would like to keep her as a friend... is that sad or healthy ? is there a way to break up but still catch up with her every 6 months or so ?

Perhaps the root problem with my situation is just my egoic desire to hold on... I think cutting down my socialization has hurt me a lot in this regard because if I was just even approaching 1 girl a week to spark a little fun harmless flirty convo with, I'd know what was out there. Or even if I was just still doing some photography of girls, that would be a big help...

My plan is to go out tonight alone for the first time in years... and just see how that feels.

Please let me know what you guys think about my situation... would breaking up be a huge mistake ? Or a great decision ? And how do I get myself to push through the pain of the breakup. I know I will feel so bad/guilty for crushing her heart since she truly does love me.

At the same time, I've also helped her grow so much in the relationship, and I've been a great boyfriend in a lot of ways. Very emotionally attentive and always helping her with her life. I've never cheated at all, and thus I can say I truly gave commitment a shot in my post-PUA-mastery life.
 
Last edited:
the right date makes getting her back home a piece of cake

Skills

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Nov 11, 2019
Messages
4,608
I need some advice and I don't know where to turn so thought I might as well give this forum a shot.

You can review some of my posting history to get a vibe on me. I leveled up in the game community quite a bit working with a good chunk of RSD coaches. I had a nice foundation of a field report thread on the RSDNation forum, which was shutdown by Owen, and looking back kind of pisses me off since I had so many field reports and lay reports written and I would've just loved to save that thread history for my own review. Enjoying the memories, and also remembering where I came from and what I went through. One of the main reasons I started that field report thread was to have something I could look back on when I am 80...

I think this is the only forum I'm found that is still active with solid advice and perspectives coming from @Chase and others. If there are better forums then let me know. I know most PUA discussion moved to fb groups, and now telegram/discords... but I think that the forum approach is much better due to the long form thought-out nature of posts... I miss the golden age of forums and there is something nostalgic/meaningful about them to me. So I'm grateful that skilledseducer.com exists at least.

Anyways, perhaps that is a bit of a scarcity mindset, and that maybe this is a good thing since it can inspire me to recreate my progress from scratch. Still it is confusing for me at times because I had been counting my lays with that field report, and now I honestly can't tell you how many girls I've hooked up with.

I've had some good winning streaks with several girls in various cold approach "romps" as I would call them. Things like 7 girls in 12 days, or 5 girls in 4 days. Overall my lay count by my best estimates is somewhere in the 150-250 range.

This probably sounds dumb but I'm honestly so hazy about the number, and I can't remember hooking up with at least 50% of the girls, which is kind of a shame, as I think having the journal records for myself is useful. Thankfully I have a few lay reports saved locally, and those all have pictures on them as well

I ended up reading through those over the last few days, and it has been sparking something within me... reminding me of who I used to be and how excited pick up would make me. I started listening to the Mystery Method on audible (a classic book that I always felt I was "too good" to read, well I'm more humble now!) and in the early parts of the book he says how cold approach gives a high like no other. I think this is why I always found it addictive. It made me feel alive.

Now, I've learned over the years that chasing the past is not a good idea. I'm not trying to reclaim my old feelings. The PUA community is not the same nowadays, since post-covid I think a lot has changed.

I'm grateful that I got to experience the PUA community. And I'm excited for the next chapter of my life, whatever communities may it hold. I've always thought that the greatest rewards possible for a PUA were as a veiled PUA. For instance, befriending celebrities and models, without ever bringing up a single word of "game". So perhaps that is the way forward for me.

--------

Anyways, I just wanted to give some context of my experience and where my head is at. Now for my current situation:

I'm now in my early 30s and I'm very confused about what to do. In a lot of ways I think I'm just rationalizing my behavior and desire for comfort. I'm someone who even before finding out about game made a decision that "if I feel discomfort then I HAVE to do it". I started facing my fears, and approaching girls was just one of those fears.

I'm currently in a committed monogamous relationship. I already know I'm going to get hated for some of the things I'm about to say...

Here's how it all started:

I had been grinding my PUA journey religiously, and progressing with ups and downs. However I had an underlying sense that something was missing. COVID was very challenging for me... in that, I wanted to keep approaching and pursuing game. Man I tried my hardest but certain sparks were missing. I had to bust my ass just to get in a few approaches, and really go out of my way even in a great game city like Vegas. Before COVID it wasn't like this... To top this all off, RSD kinda pussed out on cold approach content. They scrubbed their youtube of videos that I found immensely valuable. I wish I could download some of the free tour panels in particular, as I had access to some on a MEGA link, but then that MEGA got deleted.

I know that I was missing something, and for whatever reason I started to gravitate to a more "serial monogamy" kind of mindset. I had never been very good at managing legit rotations. And, I kind of just started seeing how long I could keep a relationship going. However, most of the time since I was traveling so much, my go-to was flying girls to visit me... after doing this several times, I know it has pros and cons.

Living in Vegas kinda sucks... and that's part of the issue. I should have moved to LA or Miami sooner. Vegas is more of a spot to practice game for a few months at max. You need to have a homebase city outside vegas and then use Vegas as a secondary city. This is very powerful especially if your homebase city is LA.

So, I would fly girls out that I had gamed while traveling, and kinda just lean on them for emotional support. I liked the feminine energy. I suppose I've always struggled to have a work-game balance. I feel like I could hang with girls or be on the phone with a girl for hours and hours, and let everything else in my life collapse. I use relationships as escapism, and have always had bad boundaries.

So, I had one short relationship that lasted about a month. And then a few months later I had another girl, let's call her G, I had hooked up with that I wanted to fly out. At the time I just thought "I like this girl, of course I want to see her again" and since she lived in a different city, flying her out was the way to do that. Following that trip, I had made some future projections about visiting her, which over the following 2 months, she started to drill me being like "you're never going to come see me, are you?" etc, even though I intended to see her, I was just very caught up with business stuff. In fact, I got very sucked into business and stock trading during this time, basically giving up game completely to just focus all on business and stock-trading.

I was addicted to stock trading, and had made a lot of money due to some insane initial luck, that I slowly but surely lost over the coming year. During this time period I did visit her for about a month (it isn't lost on me that this is a long period of time to visit someone). At the time I thought I was "so cool" for gaming a girl to let me stay at her place for so long... kinda like Ashton Klutcher in the movie "Spread". Due to the stock-trading addiction, it fried my dopamine system quite a bit.. and for a time made it hard for me to do basic life actions (and this basically would come and go over the last 2 years, depending on how addicted I was.)

When I visited her, she told me that she loved me after a few weeks, which I wasn't ready to say back. I must admit at this time I was very confused about love and what it means (being from a PUA background, I understand pair-bonding vs the societal narrative of "one true love").

I'm still confused about love and what it means exactly. We then stuck together since that trip, with her visiting me numerous times over a year until we eventually moved in with each other in a 2 bedroom apartment, where we split the rent. Before moving in, the relationship had progressed as she demanded monogamy from me, which I relented, as I was very vulnerable due to my stock trading addiction, and had basically been relying on her for 100% of my emotional support. Months later, I started to reground myself, and find other forms of support, but still leaning on her from time to time.

Even before moving in with her I was hesitant. I am pretty introverted and having someone in my day-to-day living space can cause me a lot of anxiety/annoyance. As I am really organized and basically OCD with having my living areas perfectly optimized towards my goals.

From my recent FR journal on this site:

"I'm sacrificing personal space as a challenge to see if I can hold my frame and integrate my day-to-day life while being around women. One of my desires is to live in a mansion with 3-5 girls living with me, so I view this as a learning experience for that future scenario.

the PUA lifestyle I live is very different compared to the person I present on my social media. It is very odd to spend 4-5 nights a week cold approaching for hours. I'm trying to find a way to integrate this girl into that lifestyle so that I can have more threesomes."

So, I think part of moving in together, was me again trying to challenge myself in this way... I was thinking that the next level to my game was to become completely aligned and confident in my lifestyle... having girls around 24/7 would basically force nonstop congruence tests UNTIL I become fully congruent and more grounded in my desires and who I am/want to be.

And, I would say that having a LTR did accomplish this. Im not sure if it was the best progression in my game... but it's good to know that my initial goals did get accomplished to some degree... (although maybe this is me just rationalizing getting into a relationship lmao).

However, having the LTR came at a huge sacrifice in that I naturally fell victim to comfort thinking... letting my physical fitness and social skills degrade.

Moving in kinda started off on a bad foot, as the processing of combining possessions like that is fairly annoying and inefficient. I spent easily 100+ hours just slowly trying to get G to change her organizational habits, as she is the type of person who just leaves clutter everywhere and doesn't want to sort through and organize things. (probably learning here that I need a super organized type A girl for a relationship lol - which I know there are a lot of them out there)

Living together in a lot of ways just allowed her to whip me more and more. I gave up photography, as she didn't want me with other girls. I stopped going out or socializing all together, as I didn't really have friends or any reason to.

I admittedly was singularly focused on money, and trying to make enough so that I had that area of my life handled, just as I had the girls area of my life handled by achieving a decent level of mastery in PUA.

I kept telling myself "I'll just keep dating her until my money is handled, because her support is useful and I don't have the time to go out really". I think this is a selfish reason to have a relationship... but in some regard it made sense. But, I also know if I was single, I'd be socializing more which would also be better for my mental health, motivation, etc. Having a gf is draining a lot of the time.

I had ups and downs with money, and our relationship grew more and more distant, although I think it is more of a one-sided distance. I feel distant from her, while she is still loving and attached. I feel pretty much 0 sex drive with her, and no interest in having sex, even though she is just as attractive as when I met her. One thing that concerned me is that I would try to be vulnerable with her, and she would sometimes get triggered into a lot of anger, saying very hurtful things. I've told her numerous times that this makes my love for her weaken... but she doesn't seem to understand that, and has said that "fights happen and it's not a big deal, get over it".

To me it's very confusing to be so vulnerable with someone and for them to say such hurtful things... it makes all of G's support feel like false support that I can't truly rely on. I'm not sure if it makes sense or not to rely on a girl for support anymore... maybe a rotation of girls, but not a single girl as a support system, since it's a conflict of interest with the romantic side of the relationship.

We did eventually move out of the apartment, and she was staying in airbnbs + with her parents while I have had to be out of town for a work contract for the last 2 months.

So, first off, thank god we moved out. Because breaking up while living together would SUCK ASS. Having to deal with the lease etc.

So, I have a bit of freedom right now, which is nice in comparison to the trapped feelings I felt when we shared the apt. Still we are "together" right now.

Right before I left for the work trip, we had a fight because she was asking "why don't you say you love me anymore?" And I just opened up to her, that I haven't really been feeling much love to her, and that our connection has been weakening. I did mention that every time she yells at me, it weakens our bond. I still feel a bond to her, but it's much more like a father/daughter bond or love.... and reminds me of what Esther Vilar says in "the polygamous sex" which my gut tells me is an accurate model for men's desires/tendencies.

And now, we've still been texting everyday and calling most days.

Fortunately, I do feel like just in the last couple weeks I've had a few things align in terms of productivity that I just feel in a much more competent place.

In terms of money, I now have a consistent business income. it isn't massive, but it's more than enough to keep me living comfortable, pay off credit card debt over time, and I have a clear path towards scaling. I also have some other business stuff I'm working on that ties into some passions of mine in a low risk way. Everything business-wise just seems more accessible now that I'm in my 30s, like I just have a better vantage point on how business works.

However, on the other side, I'm scared to leave the relationship for a few reasons.

1. First off, I haven't done a legit approach in a while. I'm considering just doing some tonight to see how it feels. I know that once I get past the first few approaches, most of my game skills will come rushing back to me in a more refined state. One part of me KNOWS that I have the potential to have the strongest game I've ever had if I just simply take my learnings from this LTR and carry it forward.

I'm not sure where I read this, but somewhere was saying that LTRs are the best thing you can do for your game longterm anyways... I'm excited to see if this is true, or just rationalization.

2. Second of all, part of the reason I "allowed" a relationship to happen is because I was started to get scared of improper PUA. A guy I know got charged with sexual assault, and I had an odd lay report where the girl was completely down but then he friends were freaking out and yelling at me for hooking up with her. It was 1000% consensual. I even got consent, but it still triggered some trauma/worry in me... The solution to this would obviously be to dial in my game and make sure to make the girls chase before hooking up, and be conscious of my status/value positioning. IE: running a strict quality level of game and never getting lazy with my game.

3. Third, G is extremely loyal, and it's mostly a personality quality. I wonder that if I wanted another LTR how easy it would be to find a girl this loyal, or if I'm overthinking it and with good enough game I can get loyal LTRs easily if I wanted. She is loving as well, but has times of aloofness and anger too, so not 100% loving, while we were living together there were many fights, where I had to spend 4-8 hours talking to her, to figure out common ground. This actually taught me a lot about communication and conflict resolution... but overall my boundaries were not strong enough. A lot of our fights ended in me appeasing her or stopping the behavior that she didn't like me doing... So yeah I basically was getting whipped.

See, part of me feels like as a man in my 30s, I shouldn't be in a relationship, that it's not allowing me to prioritize my mission and my businesses. Marrying this girl and settling down with kids would just feel like such a bitch move. And to top it off, I just really miss having sex with new girls. I miss the chase of PUA. And, I have so much potential to fuck so many super hot girls due to my understanding of game and psychology... even with just doing photography, whether that's model or onlyfans photography.

Another separate challenge is I don't know if nude/onlyfans photography is something I can do, since over the last year of relationship I started to understand how bad porn is affecting young men, and I'm not sure if I can contribute to that and still feel good about myself... that's a whole separate topic that deserves a post of it's own... so maybe I'll post that in the general thread later on !

Overall though, I think that's the cognitive dissonance as well... on one side I feel like I should embody good values and have a girlfriend and be a good traditional society "role model", please my parents, etc. On the other side I know I just love fucking new girls. I love PUA. And that will never go aware. I think of hugh hefner at age 80 having a smile on his face as he tells you how hot his 2 girlfriends are. I feel like as a man it's one of the most joyous and integral parts of my life, and all the positive experiences I can give to so many other girls out there..

But yeah.... idk

I feel like breaking up with her is the best decision for me. But, with having low boundaries, it's difficult for me to break up with any girl. I'm like super avoidant and non-confrontational... it's something I'm scared to even talk about... However, in business I'm able to have boundaries and walk away from money all the time if it's not a good fit. Maybe I have more abundance with money.

With love/LTR, maybe I'm just in scarcity ? I've almost just been waiting for her to break up with me... and hoping she does... but at the same time if she did try to break up with me, I'd probably fight for the relationship... maybe this is codependence ? Or ego preservation... pair bonding preservation drive ?

I feel like the answer may be the same feelings I felt as when I quit my corporate job to pursue online business.... a lot of my mind was telling me I was making a terrible decision... but my gut knew within that discomfort was the greatest growth possible for my life... and what followed was 4 years of a seriously epic PUA journey ! And I would not be anywhere close to the man I am today, without quitting that soul-sucking 9-5

And now, I sit here... ~3 years after that PUA journey ended and I drifted into this relationship... which also feels like it has drained a lot of my soul and passion from my life.

3 whole years.... and I learned a ton about LTRs and communication and business and managing my stock trading addiction and cutting out porn as well, as when I was into PUA I never had an issue with porn... once in a committed relationship though, it became too tempting... definitely messed me up a bit, but I think it was good for me to see how a man could get sucked into porn. And what so many men are facing who are stuck in marriages they despise.

But yeah at the same time, I've read @Chase 's article on "how to break up" several times... and I know it says to first present it as a break, to revisit in 30 days... but I have no confidence in my ability to break up and hold myself to it. In a lot of ways I've started to understand why abused women stay with their abusers.... a relationship can create a codependent bond that creates this emotional "haze" of not seeing how I can be without them... even though logically that I 100% can and would 99% be going to the gym more, working harder on business and creating more value for the world without her.

I suppose us being away for 2 months has given her a head start on the de-bonding process as @Skills referenced in this post: https://www.skilledseducer.com/thre...e-pair-bond-rush-from-pure-evil-repost.26831/

But yeah... it's just odd to me that it's so hard to break up. I think the finality of it is what is hard. I have no interest in sex with my girlfriend nowadays, but I would like to keep her as a friend... is that sad or healthy ? is there a way to break up but still catch up with her every 6 months or so ?

Perhaps the root problem with my situation is just my egoic desire to hold on... I think cutting down my socialization has hurt me a lot in this regard because if I was just even approaching 1 girl a week to spark a little fun harmless flirty convo with, I'd know what was out there. Or even if I was just still doing some photography of girls, that would be a big help...

My plan is to go out tonight alone for the first time in years... and just see how that feels.

Please let me know what you guys think about my situation... would breaking up be a huge mistake ? Or a great decision ? And how do I get myself to push through the pain of the breakup. I know I will feel so bad/guilty for crushing her heart since she truly does love me.

At the same time, I've also helped her grow so much in the relationship, and I've been a great boyfriend in a lot of ways. Very emotionally attentive and always helping her with her life. I've never cheated at all, and thus I can say I truly gave commitment a shot in my post-PUA-mastery life.
that shit about flying women, for me is shit! and beta as fuck! boarderline desperate, but hey! that is me.... the way you went about going into a relationship "gun to your head" is weak... that is not how per article how you go into a relationship.... All women will want containment and for you to chose them and settle... You did it, even though you did not want to... weak as fuck...


and read my how to break up and the break up dynamics, after that if you have any question shoot....


 

Chase

Chieftan
Staff member
tribal-elder
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
5,952
@ChrisVirtue,

Lots going on there!

Sorry to hear about the loss of the field reports / lay reports, man.

Can you find that stuff on archive.org?

Although I think RSDNation hid its forum behind a login screen after the Julian media blowup, IIRC.

Sad fact of life: if you really want to have something down the line, you've gotta make sure you save it yourself.

Stuff on the web just disappears...

Re: the girlfriend personality clashes -- read this article:


And probably pick up the book I talk about in it.

Your girlfriend's a Type 8.

You sound like a Type 2.

That's a pretty rough combination!

About Type 8s, Herman Melville puts a good quote into the mouth of Stubb, the second mate in Moby Dick, as he argues with Starbuck, the first mate:

Stubb said:
Thou reddenest and palest; my heat has melted thee to anger-glow. But look ye, Starbuck, what is said in heat, that thing unsays itself. There are men from whom warm words are small indignity. I meant not to incense thee. Let it go.

That's how it is with Type 8s. They are classic "their bark is worse than their bite" types.

They lose their tempers quick, flare up, bark out some nasty stuff, then calm down quick and forget all about what they said. Then later will say they didn't really mean it and just had to get the emotion out.

It's weird when you are not that way, because you'll be going, "Well, I wouldn't say something like that unless I meant it. So if that person is saying that, I have to assume she also means it," but she actually doesn't.

Weird!

Anyway, you've got the itch to maybe sorta get back to it again.

You can go out, make some approaches, see how it goes; decide from there.

Girl sounds like a pretty good girl. The annoyance from her intermittent hot-tempered outbursts not withstanding.

I guess the question is, "What do you want with her?"

Sounds like primarily emotional support.

Incidentally, I just read this today... from some guy I've never heard of named "Ricky Raw" who had a blog back around 2012-ish... someone archived this article of his and threw it into a Dropbox. Talks about how a lot of PUAs are actually codependent... might be relevant here:

On guys in the PUA community being codependent

I found it pretty insightful, based on some of the stuff I have seen over the years from a lot of guys in this space.

Let us know how it goes dipping your toes back into the water!

Chase

edit: here is a comment I made on X/Twitter today in reference to that codependent article... might also be relevant to what you are dealing with:

Chase said:
Insightful perspective in that article.

I’ve always been a bit mystified how hostile a lot of guys were in the old seduction community and are now in the red pill community to “AFCs”, “chodes”, “beta blue pill cucks”, etc.

It’s clearly a kind of status defense mechanism — basically bullying — mixed with a kind of tough-love thing where the guy builds himself up by tearing others down, and at the same time reminds himself to “stay alpha.”

I always have to talk to these guys and tell them, “You realize you can hold frame and pick up and fuck girls without having to be Mr. Rigid Cartoonish SUPER ALPHA, right?”

But if a lot of guys are codependent and they’re doing that as a coping mechanism to paper over their tendencies to white knight, simp, turn beta, etc… basically, these dudes are “betas at heart” so have to work all the harder to puff up their chests and declare “I AM ALPHA!” — yeah, that makes really good sense.

Huh.
 
Last edited:

Atlas IV

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
May 21, 2023
Messages
237
Hey man, reading your story really resonated with me. I was in a pretty similar situation last year. Sucked into crypto trading, lost a ton of money (and later gained it back) during which I was stressed, anxious and emotionally dependent on my girlfriend at the time. She wanted monogamy, I weakly accepted. After traveling together, we moved in together and she basically became my entire social life for over a year. She was an amazing, beautiful 21yo, but I was miserable in that situation. Felt like I was in a voluntary prison that I was too much of a wuss to walk out from.

That ended this year, a couple of months after I turned 30. We broke up (I really had to axe it which wasn't easy, but the only way to end it with proper finality). But after that I had 6 of the BEST months of my life. I went back to PUA and absolutely leveled up my game with tons of material I've never tried before (sex talk gambits, revamped fundamentals, etc). Went on adventures around the world, picked up girls in different countries, made loads of interesting friends, and achieved so many personal goals I'd been putting off forever.

I could not have done ANY of that if I'd stayed in the relationship. It was eating away my life energy and keeping me from realizing my potential.

From your story, it sounds like you might be feeling the same way right now. So if you've got a life you want to live, and you think marrying this girl and having a family with her would be a bitch move, then I think that fire inside you isn't going to get any weaker. You'd better just make a decision and get on with your life. These are your golden years that you're wasting if you don't. You'll only look back on it and regret not taking control sooner (as I do).

Just my 2c. And I agree that this forum is the absolute best. I was reading GC for years, but only took PUA seriously this year when I started getting active on this forum. This might be the very last bastion of proper fact-based seduction out there.

Hope to see more of you here! Sounds like we're cut from the same cloth.
 

ChrisVirtue

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Apr 6, 2019
Messages
118
that shit about flying women, for me is shit! and beta as fuck! boarderline desperate, but hey! that is me.... the way you went about going into a relationship "gun to your head" is weak... that is not how per article how you go into a relationship.... All women will want containment and for you to chose them and settle... You did it, even though you did not want to... weak as fuck...


and read my how to break up and the break up dynamics, after that if you have any question shoot....



Appreciate your response.

Not sure why paying for a girl's flight is "beta". If I fly 2 girls out to have a 3some with me, that's beta ?

To me I've always been taught (and learned) that when it comes to paying for something that solves logistics it's completely fine. Ex: a girl is broke and wants to see me but can't afford an uber, there's nothing wrong with dropping $20 to pay for an uber, unless you are also broke.

ie: if a flight is a lot of money to you, then it's beta. But if it's a small amount (most of these flights were like $70-$150) then I just view it as an uber. The more beta part would be letting the girl stay longer than I want or letting her impact my lifestyle negatively while she is visiting. A lot of this can be mitigated by just having a big enough house with multiple bedrooms so that I can accommodate her while also having freedom.

I agree 100% the way I got into a relationship was weak as fuck. As I mentioned the issue is that I was weak due to external stuff. My gambling addiction was spiraling and I had low self-esteem and a lot of anxiety, and didn't want to lose the emotional support. If I lost her in that time period, it could have led me to a much worse situation... so I clung onto the support that I had, compromising my values and my ideal version of myself, just to keep myself from going to an even worse version of myself.

Weak monogamy ChrisVirtue >>> Suicidally depressed ChrisVirtue

I see a lot of RP guys preaching monogamy and idk how much of it is cope. I feel like having multiple girls that love you is fine, once you accept and anticipate that the girls will eventually fall off and have to be rotated/replaced, just like running a business, employees will retire over time and need to be rotated/replaced. Nothing is permanent.

One thing is for sure. In 10 years I'll be 40 and this girl would be 38. There is 0 chance I'll be attracted to her, considering right now I don't have any interest in sex with her.

This is actually worth writing here for my future self:

- If I look at my girlfriend's IG pics it turns me on and attracts me, makes me want to fuck her.

- However, if I just look at her IRL, I'm not interested in sex at all.

The weird thing about this is, she doesn't even look massively different in her pics.... she does look way worse with 0 makeup though (as is the case with most girls).

But, it's not to do with her attractiveness. Her attractiveness is very high (signed model).

It's just that fucking the same girl over and over is soul-sucking.

As a man I need variety, and I'd much rather break up and say goodbye to monogamy/being whipped than to cheat (which to me is weak asf).
 
Last edited:

ChrisVirtue

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Apr 6, 2019
Messages
118
@ChrisVirtue,

Lots going on there!

Sorry to hear about the loss of the field reports / lay reports, man.

Can you find that stuff on archive.org?

Although I think RSDNation hid its forum behind a login screen after the Julian media blowup, IIRC.

Sad fact of life: if you really want to have something down the line, you've gotta make sure you save it yourself.

Stuff on the web just disappears...

Re: the girlfriend personality clashes -- read this article:


And probably pick up the book I talk about in it.

Your girlfriend's a Type 8.

You sound like a Type 2.

That's a pretty rough combination!

About Type 8s, Herman Melville puts a good quote into the mouth of Stubb, the second mate in Moby Dick, as he argues with Starbuck, the first mate:



That's how it is with Type 8s. They are classic "their bark is worse than their bite" types.

They lose their tempers quick, flare up, bark out some nasty stuff, then calm down quick and forget all about what they said. Then later will say they didn't really mean it and just had to get the emotion out.

It's weird when you are not that way, because you'll be going, "Well, I wouldn't say something like that unless I meant it. So if that person is saying that, I have to assume she also means it," but she actually doesn't.

Weird!

Anyway, you've got the itch to maybe sorta get back to it again.

You can go out, make some approaches, see how it goes; decide from there.

Girl sounds like a pretty good girl. The annoyance from her intermittent hot-tempered outbursts not withstanding.

I guess the question is, "What do you want with her?"

Sounds like primarily emotional support.

Incidentally, I just read this today... from some guy I've never heard of named "Ricky Raw" who had a blog back around 2012-ish... someone archived this article of his and threw it into a Dropbox. Talks about how a lot of PUAs are actually codependent... might be relevant here:

On guys in the PUA community being codependent

I found it pretty insightful, based on some of the stuff I have seen over the years from a lot of guys in this space.

Let us know how it goes dipping your toes back into the water!

Chase

edit: here is a comment I made on X/Twitter today in reference to that codependent article... might also be relevant to what you are dealing with:

Thanks for the response and all the resources !

Yeah I tried using archive.org right when RSDNation shut down... but it wouldn't navigate to my thread. I think my only hope is contacting Owen directly since I would imagine they would have backed it up somewhere... but who knows. Maybe I'll ask Owen about it one day next time I'm with him in-person.


I have bought the Enneagram book and will give your thread a read before fleshing out my thoughts.

I also downloaded that codependent pdf and am reading it right now... again will want to process my thoughts on these resources before making a proper response !


I did go out on Sat Night (wrote a brief field report in my SS journal).


It went pretty awesome, and made me feel a lot more alive. I think what I've decided on in the meantime is that regardless when having a GF, I still need to be more social and do some approaches. I talked to my GF about that I want to start going out to bars for "guys night" with a few friends more consistently, under the frame of "a healthy relationship needs this" which is honestly how I feel about it now. And she was cool with the idea of it.

Of course, it will definitely provoke shit tests/drama from her, especially if she finds out im flirting/cold approaching. But, I'm prepared to deal with those shit tests/drama, and setting a boundary with this, that im willing to leave of course if she's not cool with it (also I'm probably going to end up breaking up anyhow).

So, I'm thinking I just want to do a bare minimum of 5-10 approaches per week, so at least I still have some degree of social momentum/abundance if the relationship ends.

At the very least, I noticed going out gave me more confidence in the relationship, like easier for me to have boundaries etc. Probably coming from the abundance mindset of seeing my ability to approach and get attraction.

Mystery recommends 48 approaches per week... so I'm debating trying to maintain this, so that I can "overshoot" the bare minimum.... but that might be unrealistic depending on my lifestyle... I mean it's not that crazy just need to do 2-4 game sessions per week with 12-24 approaches in each. Not that hard to do if I just do a proper full night of night game in target-rich environment 2x per week.

Bottom line is I know I need a bare minimum target otherwise I won't do it while in a relationship or busy with work.

Reminds me of what Owen said in those truth about success videos: "there's never a convenient time for me to go to the gym or go do approaches."

I feel the same with both... it's never convenient, so I need a bare minimum accountability target !
 
Last edited:

Skills

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Nov 11, 2019
Messages
4,608
Appreciate your response.

Not sure why paying for a girl's flight is "beta". If I fly 2 girls out to have a 3some with me, that's beta ?

To me I've always been taught (and learned) that when it comes to paying for something that solves logistics it's completely fine. Ex: a girl is broke and wants to see me but can't afford an uber, there's nothing wrong with dropping $20 to pay for an uber, unless you are also broke.

ie: if a flight is a lot of money to you, then it's beta. But if it's a small amount (most of these flights were like $70-$150) then I just view it as an uber. The more beta part would be letting the girl stay longer than I want or letting her impact my lifestyle negatively while she is visiting. A lot of this can be mitigated by just having a big enough house with multiple bedrooms so that I can accommodate her while also having freedom.

^ yes, now that i see your answer you are correct, i apologize, i was thinking the dubai type dudes simping..... In your context is good, like you said paying ubber, paying for hotel to fuck, etc... is not beta, but as you say solving logistic, if it was your idea vs she demanding just like buying drinks... again i am 100% wrong in your context you are 100% correct...
I agree 100% the way I got into a relationship was weak as fuck. As I mentioned the issue is that I was weak due to external stuff. My gambling addiction was spiraling and I had low self-esteem and a lot of anxiety, and didn't want to lose the emotional support. If I lost her in that time period, it could have led me to a much worse situation... so I clung onto the support that I had, compromising my values and my ideal version of myself, just to keep myself from going to an even worse version of myself.

Weak monogamy ChrisVirtue >>> Suicidally depressed ChrisVirtue

yeah
I see a lot of RP guys preaching monogamy and idk how much of it is cope. I feel like having multiple girls that love you is fine, once you accept and anticipate that the girls will eventually fall off and have to be rotated/replaced, just like running a business, employees will retire over time and need to be rotated/replaced. Nothing is permanent.
it is cope, and rp are mostly kjs anyways or money grabbers...
One thing is for sure. In 10 years I'll be 40 and this girl would be 38. There is 0 chance I'll be attracted to her, considering right now I don't have any interest in sex with her.

you don't know this... some women look max just like dudes.... but yea at least 5- 10 years younger or more... but you don't want them to young for ltr inmho...
This is actually worth writing here for my future self:

- If I look at my girlfriend's IG pics it turns me on and attracts me, makes me want to fuck her.

- However, if I just look at her IRL, I'm not interested in sex at all.

The weird thing about this is, she doesn't even look massively different in her pics.... she does look way worse with 0 makeup though (as is the case with most girls).

But, it's not to do with her attractiveness. Her attractiveness is very high (signed model).

It's just that fucking the same girl over and over is soul-sucking.

As a man I need variety, and I'd much rather break up and say goodbye to monogamy/being whipped than to cheat (which to me is weak asf).
between you and your dick...
 

ChrisVirtue

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Apr 6, 2019
Messages
118
^ yes, now that i see your answer you are correct, i apologize, i was thinking the dubai type dudes simping..... In your context is good, like you said paying ubber, paying for hotel to fuck, etc... is not beta, but as you say solving logistic, if it was your idea vs she demanding just like buying drinks... again i am 100% wrong in your context you are 100% correct...

No worries. Yeah I think it would be beta if you fly a girl out and think it's gonna make you fuck her, take her on shopping sprees, and buy her purses etc thinking it's gonna make her like you more. I mainly fly out girls I've already fucked, and I definitely wouldn't take em on a shopping spree etc. If I flew out a girl who I hadn't hooked up with and she didn't put out, I would prob just fly her home the next day.

I've worked hard to avoid that frame, and disqualify etc... I always am making it like not a big deal that I'm flying them out. Also I sometimes book refundable flights. I've even cancelled girls flights before bc I got busy lol.


it is cope, and rp are mostly kjs anyways or money grabbers...

Yeah. Alex Hormozi is one of em who is just cope imo. His wife is ugly yet he copes saying "I needed a wife solved so I can focus on my business."

The obvious counterpoint is... if you have good game you can still get laid with minimal time per week, and I'd argue that it's not something you can just give up... to me it's the same thing as saying "I'm not gonna hit the gym until I make $10mil"... As men we need to take care of all areas of our life and be careful to not delusionally prevent our growth in ANY area (fitness, mental health, money, seduction are the core 4 I personally believe every man needs weekly routines on to stay on the right path)


you don't know this... some women look max just like dudes.... but yea at least 5- 10 years younger or more... but you don't want them to young for ltr inmho...

My GF does looksmaxx herself quite a bit... she is def a girl who made herself more hot over time... so yeah she wants all sorts of surgeries so I guess she could be "hotter" but to me the age is unattractive... I'd much prefer girls in the 19-25 range.

between you and your dick...

What do you mean by this ?
 

ChrisVirtue

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Apr 6, 2019
Messages
118
@ChrisVirtue,

Lots going on there!

Sorry to hear about the loss of the field reports / lay reports, man.

Can you find that stuff on archive.org?

Although I think RSDNation hid its forum behind a login screen after the Julian media blowup, IIRC.

Sad fact of life: if you really want to have something down the line, you've gotta make sure you save it yourself.

Stuff on the web just disappears...

Re: the girlfriend personality clashes -- read this article:


And probably pick up the book I talk about in it.

Your girlfriend's a Type 8.

You sound like a Type 2.

That's a pretty rough combination!

About Type 8s, Herman Melville puts a good quote into the mouth of Stubb, the second mate in Moby Dick, as he argues with Starbuck, the first mate:



That's how it is with Type 8s. They are classic "their bark is worse than their bite" types.

They lose their tempers quick, flare up, bark out some nasty stuff, then calm down quick and forget all about what they said. Then later will say they didn't really mean it and just had to get the emotion out.

It's weird when you are not that way, because you'll be going, "Well, I wouldn't say something like that unless I meant it. So if that person is saying that, I have to assume she also means it," but she actually doesn't.

Weird!

Anyway, you've got the itch to maybe sorta get back to it again.

You can go out, make some approaches, see how it goes; decide from there.

Girl sounds like a pretty good girl. The annoyance from her intermittent hot-tempered outbursts not withstanding.

I guess the question is, "What do you want with her?"

Sounds like primarily emotional support.

Incidentally, I just read this today... from some guy I've never heard of named "Ricky Raw" who had a blog back around 2012-ish... someone archived this article of his and threw it into a Dropbox. Talks about how a lot of PUAs are actually codependent... might be relevant here:

On guys in the PUA community being codependent

I found it pretty insightful, based on some of the stuff I have seen over the years from a lot of guys in this space.

Let us know how it goes dipping your toes back into the water!

Chase

edit: here is a comment I made on X/Twitter today in reference to that codependent article... might also be relevant to what you are dealing with:

Hey @Chase

I did finally finish reading that codependency article. It took me a while to finish it after reading the half immediately after you shared. (let me know if you have access to the other articles in the series btw)

SUPER SUPER interesting...

I found most of the ideas to be spot on, and sparked different thinking within me regarding PUA. It put a lot of words to things that I had felt for a long time, but didn't know how to express.

I think it's true, that in game, the premise of learning PUA for many men is rooted in achieving female validation.

A much healthier frame of mind is simply that game is fun and a fun thing to learn to "have more fun".

The article roughly describes how I'm feeling nowadays with somewhat of a "Reawakening" to look at PUA through a different, post-monogamous relationship lens.



I feel like for me the article is very accurate. I have tendencies that align with the qualities of a codependent.

Particularly:
1. have difficulty identifying what Im feeling and minimize/deny how I feel (I do this with my gf all the time and how I feel negatively about being restricted in a monogamous relationship)

2. have difficulty making decisions, judge myself harshly as not good enough (I'm a HUGE perfectionist, and so indecisive. I always have so many projects going on and can never explicitly decide on an identity/career to pursue)

3. embarrassed to receive praise/gifts (im always trying to hide my successes...)

4. unable to identify or ask for what I need and want (this one is HUGE in the relationship I literally don't know what I want, and it's very difficult for me to remember or think of what I want)

5. compromise values and integrity to avoid rejection and other's anger (I literally compromised my values when entering this relationship, and am compromising my values every day im with her)

6. sensitive to other's feelings and assume the same feelings (I have this heavily... so much that I assume myself to be a HSP highly sensitive person)

7. believe people are incapable of taking care of themselves (I find myself thinking this way with my girlfriend WAY too much, while logically I know she should take care of herself I buy way too much into her bullshit "oh I can't clean up after myself since I was raised like this" etc)

8. Attempt to convince others what to think, do, feel and become resentful when others decline my help or reject my advice (I do this so much, and never thought of it as codependent behavior... I'm ALWAYS trying to influence others, and tbh PUA must fall into this pretty neatly. But yeah the resentful thing happens to me. And it's confusing, but I end relationships when friends dont take my advice since it annoys me and feels to me like it means my advice wasn't correct - it messes with my beliefs too much)

9. Freely offer advice and direction without being asked (I do this ALL THE TIME. And it's funny because I HATE when others do it to me. It's one of my pet peeves in others. Don't offer unsolicited advice.)

10. Judge harshly what others think say or do (I always need to find something wrong in others... at least one thing, to then invalidate all the GOOD THINGS about that person. I find myself doing this automatically and I don't like it... it's retarded).

11. Avoid emotional, physical, sexual intimacy to avoid feeling vulnerable (I'M LITERALLY FEELING THIS RIGHT NOW WITH MY GF)



What's odd to me is that I also feel narcissistic tendencies as well...

Things like:
- enjoying attention/validation and being the center of attention
- preferring to be the smartest/most respected person in the room
- using elaborate reasonings and analysis to come to the conclusion that I'm cooler than everyone else, even when I'm objectively not
- being very sensitive to criticism or negative feedback


In fact, I'd say from the codependent list I just wrote, I would have thought #8, #9, #10 are all narcissistic traits... The fact that they are considered codependent is pretty confusing to me.


All this codependent VS narcissistic stuff is very confusing to me as well.


I would assume that desire control over others is a more narcissistic thing as well...

Now that I'm thinking about it... I guess the desire for control is basically a desire for controlled validation. A codependent learns PUA to control the validation they receive, they can get it as much as they want... but it's still codependency because it's rooted in a need to get validation. The codependent who masters PUA has just gotten REALLY GOOD at getting that validation, but it's all coming from a place of scarcity, in which they had to learn this complex system of what to do to get that validation.


I almost think I didn't understand what narcissism was. I assumed narcissist was just an extremely confident person, who is just very into themselves, and grounded in their own validation.

But, researching says that they often have an unstable sense of self-worth, which they try to protect through a façade of superiority... need for control is common for narcissists as well.

So...

overall it seems like codependents and narcissists have many overlapping traits and there is subtleties to this.


That's why my gut with all this shit is often like "ok so these 'disorders' exist... but I also prefer to take all of it with a grain of salt, since it's a soft science."

The real question to me, is what do I practically do with this stuff ? and how do I even know how to not be a codependent or narcissist...?

What is the healthy behavior and how do I embody it ?



Anyways, the article sparked a lot of this type of thinking in me. The compensatory narcissist makes a lot of sense, and it sounds like a normal coping mechanism for codependent type people who don't get into PUA as well... it's just a good way to cover up the vulnerabilities or weaknesses.


For now, I recognize at the very least that I would rather lean on the edge of being MORE CAREFUL about being taken advantage as a codependent...

With my girlfriend, I'm recognizing that I'm not living up to my life standards and MY VALUES aren't being met !


So, the first step towards moving towards my life standards and MY VALUES is breaking up.


And, maybe this is the codependent within me talking but... it's like whenever I think of breaking up I have an internal blocker that just starts making up reasons to not do it. It's like I turn to stone.

Being around my girlfriend is just nonstop comfort and NEGATIVE growth. The more I'm around her, the worse I feel, the worse habits I adopt. She's not a good influence on me...

Maybe that's the map for any future relationship... she must be pulling me up rather than pulling me down ?


The issue with my GF is that the first 3-6 months were so good and I got addicted to that good behavior (100% nonstop amazing support)

Now, that has me worried that the same pattern will happen where girls are on their best behavior to GET the relationship/commitment, BUT as I man I NEED to be nonstop vigilant about a girl's negative behavior and make sure to not reward/validate/enable the negative behavior, and instead PUNISH IT by withdrawing validation (time, attention, emotions)
 
Last edited:
Top