What's new

Newbie: Please advise re declining situation

Seppuku

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
1,149
Hey Samson,

Your profile strikes me as very similar to mine when I joined the Boards three years ago: I was 45 years old, good job, and recently divorced after 15 years. Three years and fifty girls later, I can tell you that Girls Chase's stuff works very well, and that I'm now in a much better place with women than the 2014 poor sorry chap me.

The road ahead to getting better at girls, however, looks like this. First, you need to find a way, suitable for you, to get many, many dates with many different girls. Second, you need to avoid being trapped into a committed relationship until you get good. Third, you need to get plenty of girls to bed. When you get there, you will have a much deeper understanding of the female mentality, and you will have cleaned up the set of wrong beliefs about dating, that we all initially have when we start. It's a long road, and there will be plenty of rollercoasters coming along, but in the end you will be in a much better place - if you have the patience to go all the way (many guys settle with a girlfriend before reaching the end of the journey).

Now regarding your situation. A lot of newcomers to the Boards initially come here looking for a solution to fix a fucked up situation. The thing is, unfortunately there is no magic recipe to fix things that have gone the wrong way. The seduction arts mainly tell us what to do to maximize success ratio, starting from a clean scratch. They tell us about the common traits that women, regardless of country and culture, find universally attractive, and those that they are loathing. They tell us how to emulate those attractive traits and behaviors in the beginning, and later how to actually acquire those traits: if you live by it, and breath it, you will ultimately become it.

So I'm not going to focus on what to do or what to say to salvage the current situation, rather try to give you my thoughts about what went wrong, in the hope that you do better next time. It may not be your immediate concern, but hopefully will help you next time. I apologize in advance that I will be a little blunt and shake your ego, but understand that I mean it in a positive sense, for you to learn and improve.

You started very well! Congratulations. I'm sure you impressed on her and gave her lovable memories. But then:
when I left I said we couldn't really be a couple bc of the distance thing
Ooops! You are telling her that there cannot be a future with you. You want to avoid that! Indeed later on, you realized that you actually wanted to see her again, but most likely she had already taken your "no couple" message. You should always leave the door open. Firstly, you don't know how you will feel about it a few weeks from now, and second, if you tell a girl that there is zero chance of a future, she's going to take the message home.

As soon as I could I arranged a trip for us to spend a week together in another city, and I bought her plane ticket as she genuinely couldn't afford it.
It doesn't appear clearly who pushed for the second meeting, her or you, but I'm going to assume it was coming from you. Traditionally, men pursue sex, and women pursue relationships. Women have the power to grant the sex, men have the power to grant the relationship. Don't strip yourself of your power! Let her chase for the relationship! Assuming that you didn't close the door by telling her "we can't be a couple" of course! If she likes you, she will be the one asking to see you again. Enjoy the perks of being chased! It is a much better place to be. Of course you don't have to wait forever for her to ask - although it helps to wait and see a little. You can subtly hint about a second meeting, and let her take the bait.

The end is much less pretty, with your emotional breakdown splashing your neediness. Neediness is one of the strongest girls repellent. You're communicating that, in fact, you do not have anything else going on in your life, including other girls, which is not sexy. You're communicating that you depend on her for your happiness. You're coming from a position of weakness and lack of control, and girls absolutely loathe this. You have the right to be emotional, of course, but you should avoid to display it at all cost because it doesn't help your case. Men need to maintain an appearance of strength and control at all times. It is expected from all leaders in fact if you think about it, for instance at the office. How would it look like if the boss started to burst his emotions? What sort of respect would his guys have for him?

There is another thing going on: complete inconsistency of behavior. You started as the cool sexy guy who swept her on her feet and took a good care of her bodily needs. You ended like the needy guy who seems like having no other options in his life than her. It's what we call here non-congruence of behavior. It communicates that you are not the real deal! It is very important to always remain the same guy you were in the beginning: that sexy guy she fell for initially. If you don't, she will feel you were not for real and get some unconscious sense of being cheated on the merchandise. I call it "keeping my frame". Better losing the girl than losing the frame. I mean it literally. I have lost some girls to this principle, but overall it pays off.

Last thing. You keep repeating that she is the one wanting a relationship. Do you have any evidence in support? Or is it your assumption? We, men, are led to believe that "good girls surely are not like this", but in fact, even good girls sometimes are looking for a good fuck. They can be chasing for sex at first. I recently made a write up of the decisive experience that made me *really* understand this.

With this in mind, there is another possible reading of your story, which goes this way. She went on a vacation and found this sexy guy (you), fell for him, and "forgot" to mention about her existing boyfriend at home. It was a nice time, deliciously refreshing, and she enjoyed a lot... Then went back to the boyfriend. Later, the sexy guy tries to push for a second meeting, and now feels a little "relationship-y". That wasn't expected (she thought it was a one time thing), and now exhibits the forgotten boyfriend in the hope he picks the message.

Think about it. Could this scenario fit your story? You know the facts best. I, personally, have found more than once that some girl "forgot" to mention the BF.

Alright! I hope I wasn't too blunt. Welcome to the Boards. Looking forward to seeing you around!

Cheers,
Seppuku
 

dcman

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Apr 3, 2017
Messages
96
Dear Seppuku , I have read a large number of write ups you have made in this forum and have found them to be very insightful. But I am going to differ from what you have written in this scenario. The girl seems to have cluster b traits. My experiences with a cluster B were similar to what scot Drexel described in the comments section of this post https://www.girlschase.com/content/3-big ... -polyamory . I began the relationship with a leading frame and continued it. I had no girl scarcity mentally problem when I started or during the relationship but still ended up in being in a needful situation towards the end. In reading shrink4men.com I understood how these girls work on making even the experienced men cave in after time. Following Drexel’s advise of focusing why I ended up with a girl with these traits helped me moved forward, obtain closure and ensure it does not happen again. On the contrary If my focus had been on figuring out what went wrong with particular this girl I would have not learnt much, as interactions with these girls in my opinion do not form the base point for a guy to learn from a seduction or relationship view point.
 
the right date makes getting her back home a piece of cake

Seppuku

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
1,149
Hey dcman,

Thanks, and respect! I saw what you wrote on the cluster B aspect, and it may very well be correct! I didn't want to engage that aspect of discussion, and just wanted to focus on what I think Samson did wrong. Our contributions do not contradict, but supplement each other's.

Cheers!
Seppuku
 

Samson84

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Messages
78
Hi all,

I'd like to thank all you guys for contributing to this thread. It's been very valuable for me.

I'm gonna start out by being honest and saying I've had a really hard time with this situation, and had a couple of months being depressed and very low self esteem. The reasons for that are complex, but that's the truth.

So Seppuku, it was kinda hard to hear the things I might have done that were repellant or loathesome. Especially as I was already beating myself up on this. But I appreciate the information of what I could do differently in future. Certainly, it was not deliberate to get emotional, but at the time I didn't know what I didn't know. I just believed the girl when she said that she was out because she had the impression that I wasn't interested in relationship/commitment, so I tried to convince her of that. Which was a mistake, but yeah. Also, although I was very sincere, I didn't beg her or belittle her or anything. I just told her that I was very disappointed and upset, that I thought we were working towards something together, but I respected her choice. And that it was a shame we didn't have longer together because I found her very appealing both physically and emotionally. And I tried to find out the misunderstandings and to clear them up. But in the end it didn't change anything for her.

But in that, I probably did give her the impression that she could walk all over me, or that I was low value. However, even without that, it may not have really changed anything since by that time she was already involved with the other guy. He's right there and I'm in another country.

Now, regarding the BPD traits. This is something I've researched a lot now, and it has been fascinating and terrifying. Actually quite a lot of what I read has a high correlation with what I experienced in the breakdown of my marriage and subsequent divorce. There are a few websites dedicated to helping men recover from relationships with BPD women since the psychological and emotional fallout can be devastating.

Everyone ought to know some of this stuff. But particularly guys like me who enjoy the thrill of euphoric love sensations, or who believe in love at first sight, or have a tendency to get enmeshed or derive some of their self esteem from being with a hot girl. Personally I have issues with codependency which means that if the right chemistry is there, I can get attached too easily and experience soul-wrenching core rejection when that person ditches me. I guess it goes back to my emotionally neglectful childhood. Anyone else in this boat or is it just me?

Hence, with this girl, I didn't want to go too fast and either scare her off or get myself badly hurt. On the first date we were really into each other, and the few dates we had after that were magical and intoxicating. For me, and I'm pretty sure for her too. She was saying pretty extreme things, like how amazing I was, and no man ever treated her so well before, and how great it would be if we were a couple and I was moving to the USA, etc. She seemed to be fascinated by everything about me. However, the flattery wasn't what really hooked me. I was just totally crazy about her body and her smile, from the moment I first saw her.

dcman was kind enough to highlight from my first post, some of the things that he thought could indicate that this woman might have BPD traits. This really did me a favour, as it was the first point at which I was able to think, hang on, maybe this wasn't entirely about my shortcomings. In truth, I have logged dozens of other strange words, emotions or actions that were (or should have been) red flags. Even from the first couple of dates, I was mentally keeping a list of all the red flags as they started to build up. But I chose to ignore them because the attraction level was so high.

Some of the best resources on the web about BPD relationships are:
http://gettinbetter.com/BPDlove.html
http://www.nicolamethodforhighconflict. ... -disorder/
http://shrink4men.com/2017/04/11/love-b ... -red-flag/
http://bpdfamily.com/
and other articles on these sites.

I wish I could be sure whether this girl is (a) BPD/NPD or strong traits, in which case I may have dodged a bullet; or (b) just an incredibly sexy, sweet, seductive but somewhat immature goddess, in which case I may have lost the best thing I nearly had.

If I'm 100% honest with myself, at the very least, she is very fickle, flaky, and lied to me to protect her ego. So I just don't know.

I went on fb to unfollow her and saw her cover photo of her in her bf's arms with a huge smile. I nearly threw up.

I talked to my therapist again, and she said that BPD or no, what happened to me is a "mindfuck": holiday romance, months of staying in touch being affectionate and supportive and sexy, planned a vacation together, all seems fine, then one week before she announces she's IN LOVE with another man, their kids are playing together right now while we go swimming, because he gave her the commitment that I hadn't ... Yeah, if that's normal then I need a serious recalibration here. Again, it helped me.

So the way BPD works, often the woman pursues you just to the point where she knows she has you smitten. Whether that's weeks, months or in some cases years. The chase is everything not the actual intimacy which triggers fear of abandonment. The moment you are hooked, she no longer wants you and starts to vent her deep-seated rage upon you, blaming you for whatever. You try to fix it but you can't. So in some cases, as soon as the couple is married, or he has left his wife, or whatever, it's basically over. In other cases, it lies dormant until triggered and then all hell breaks loose (my marriage ended like this). So it may be that when she told me about her getting a bf, and accusing me of only wanting sex from her, it was a "test" of sorts, to see if I was hooked. And because I showed my deep hurt, she knew she had me and lost interest, to continue pursuing the new guy. It could also explain why her second marriage was over so quickly that she tried to get it annulled.

So I try to keep some perspective here and tell myself "not all that glitters is gold", but I often still just sob at the thought of her not being in my life any more. But that could have more to do with my own issues right now.

Anyway, I'd still like to have sex with her again. But it seems like she is probably into her bf right now, and maybe not much I can do until he screws up, or she screws it up. The only thing I can think of is to build social proof on instagram, but I'm not sure how to achieve that.

It's probably better to learn some fundamental skills with women, as Seppuku suggests. And in that, I have a couple questions... When you say it's better to lose the girl than "lose the frame", what do you mean? And why is it better? What is the whole purpose of gaining these skills and sleeping with lots of women? And with regard to not getting into a committed relationship, isn't that the whole point? I'd love to meet a fab woman that I'm super-attracted to, and who is a good match for me, and fall in love, and build a mutual relationship together. (That's what I thought was happening, hence the disappointment.) Isn't that what other people want?

I'm probably over-trusting in some respects, and I'm honest and straight in my dealings with people including women. I would consider these are strengths for relationship building, but perhaps they're not seen as sexy if they are "nice guy" traits.

Please point me at the best resources to start with becoming an Alpha Male, capable of attracting and keeping an Alpha Female. This will be my 2018 goal. Success is the best form of revenge.
 

Seppuku

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
1,149
Hey Samson,

Alright, I hope you are beginning to recover a little from this experience, and feel a bit better.
Samson84 said:
So Seppuku, it was kinda hard to hear the things I might have done that were repellant or loathesome. Especially as I was already beating myself up on this. But I appreciate the information of what I could do differently in future.
Sorry my words made you feel bad. But it was meant in a positive way, for your future benefit. I'm sure you didn't choose to become emotional. And there's nothing wrong with having emotions. But just remember to show some restraints in displaying emotional distress in the future because it *is* unattractive and does not help your case. The same holds, by the way, for expressions of frustration. I hope you got my point right.
Everyone ought to know some of this stuff. But particularly guys like me who enjoy the thrill of euphoric love sensations, or who believe in love at first sight, or have a tendency to get enmeshed or derive some of their self esteem from being with a hot girl. Personally I have issues with codependency which means that if the right chemistry is there, I can get attached too easily and experience soul-wrenching core rejection when that person ditches me. I guess it goes back to my emotionally neglectful childhood. Anyone else in this boat or is it just me?
Don't mistake us seducers on these Boards. We are not insensitive to this. We were *ALL* here before. It is not just you, we all know what it is like.
I wish I could be sure whether this girl is (a) BPD/NPD or strong traits, in which case I may have dodged a bullet; or (b) just an incredibly sexy, sweet, seductive but somewhat immature goddess, in which case I may have lost the best thing I nearly had.
This could very well be the case. There is indeed a lot of "mindfucking" aspect in this story. I didn't emphasize what others already said, and instead chose to focus on things you could improve on your end.
Anyway, I'd still like to have sex with her again. But it seems like she is probably into her bf right now, and maybe not much I can do until he screws up, or she screws it up. The only thing I can think of is to build social proof on instagram, but I'm not sure how to achieve that.
It may be best that you forget about her.
It's probably better to learn some fundamental skills with women, as Seppuku suggests. And in that, I have a couple questions... When you say it's better to lose the girl than "lose the frame", what do you mean? And why is it better? What is the whole purpose of gaining these skills and sleeping with lots of women? And with regard to not getting into a committed relationship, isn't that the whole point? I'd love to meet a fab woman that I'm super-attracted to, and who is a good match for me, and fall in love, and build a mutual relationship together. (That's what I thought was happening, hence the disappointment.) Isn't that what other people want?
As to individual goals and number of girls... I guess it depends on which phase of life guys are. Younger guys here may feel that building numbers improve their self esteem and their confidence as men. In my case, I don't mind so much of the numbers per se (although I did quite well), but more about building up the required experience in little time (the bulk of my growth as seducer came within two years). To me, the ultimate goal is to get relationships with better terms for myself.

I view getting experience as a valuable goal in itself. I have now a much better understanding of the female psyche. I am much less impressed about her beauty. I see her motivations around me, much more clearly. If tomorrow I meet a super beautiful girl that I want to keep in my life, I will have a better idea of what to do, and what not to do, and stand a better chance. And I have better relationship management skills than I ever did. Some of the stuff I wished I had known when I met my ex wife twenty years ago. Not saying it's perfect, there is still room for a lot of improvement, but it's a much, much better place now. And there was no way I could have gotten here, without raking up more than 100 dates, and nearly 50 women in bed.

I once read a book from a great seducer, in which he wrote:
All men should be kept by law from getting married or involved in a long-term relationship before they become expert seducers and have laid at least 50 women
Although it is wishful thinking to expect that to happen, there is definitely a good cause for writing this statement.

"Better losing the girl than losing my frame".
In my case, the frame is "I am a high value, attractive and sexy man". It is a very good internal belief to have, it will win you girls. So, from now on, I try my best that all my actions and words are consistent with this frame, and never depart from it. Occasionally, it may mean that I have to let the girl go, rather than contradict my frame. As a general rule, you are much better off if you are willing to let her go. If you're not, that's when you become clingy and chasey and needy, and lose the girl anyway.

An example is in my latest lay report. The girl is on my bed, she has been feeling my dick under the trousers, but she says "we cannot have sex". What does my frame dictates me to do? I cannot become supplicating, that would break my frame. The only thing I can do, as a "high value, attractive and sexy man", is tell her "the right moment to do it is now. If it doesn't happen now, it will never happen", then let go for a while and let her return to me. Which she did, and it ended nicely in bed. But I was basically telling her it's now or never, we do it now, or you lose me. She could have walked away. She didn't. My frame won over hers ("we cannot have sex"). It worked wonders, because I was self consistent in all my actions and words since the beginning. I was congruent, consistent with my frame. If I had broken in fear that she leaves, or if I had become supplicating, it would have ended here surely. Keeping my frame helped me win the girl. I have had other cases, however, where I lost the girl to my frame. But overall I have been much better off sticking to it.

Please point me at the best resources to start with becoming an Alpha Male, capable of attracting and keeping an Alpha Female. This will be my 2018 goal. Success is the best form of revenge.
Great! There are lots of resources in the "manosphere", but many of these have a negative mindset embedded, e.g. "all women are sluts". Girls Chase is the best at explaining the concepts, as well as at keeping a positive mindset. Look for the early articles of Chase where he explains the basics.

I also recommend you to read BlackDragon. He is an older man (45 years old), has a very mature thinking, with a focus on relationships.

Seppuku
 

Samson84

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Messages
78
I read Chase's guide to getting your gf back and I was kinda on the right lines.

I'm planning to send this message to reestablish contact:

Hey X, it's been a while! I'm wondering how you're doing and I hope life is treating you well. I still care about you so drop me a msg some time and let me know what's going on for you :)

What do you guys think? I really want to get back with this woman and make it work.
 

Michal

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Jul 5, 2013
Messages
278
Samson84 said:
I read Chase's guide to getting your gf back and I was kinda on the right lines.

I'm planning to send this message to reestablish contact:

Hey X, it's been a while! I'm wondering how you're doing and I hope life is treating you well. I still care about you so drop me a msg some time and let me know what's going on for you :)

What do you guys think? I really want to get back with this woman and make it work.
Hello Samson,

The "I still care about you" line does not paint you in a great light. It seems chase-y, it tells her you probably do not have any options similar to her and that is not something women find attractive or help seducing them. I know it is hard to do but I would rather send her the previous message you crafted where you said you did not want to be friends. This message you crafted here, it will do you no good.
I know how you feel but at this point it seems that her responding to you would be a success. I was in a similar situation and I was disappointed with myself that I blew it. But the male brain is set to "do something about it" and in most cases.. doing less is more.
 

Samson84

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Messages
78
Hi Michal, thanks for the sanity check here.

Michal said:
The "I still care about you" line does not paint you in a great light. It seems chase-y, it tells her you probably do not have any options similar to her and that is not something women find attractive or help seducing them. I know it is hard to do but I would rather send her the previous message you crafted where you said you did not want to be friends. This message you crafted here, it will do you no good.

Ok, that's good to know.

Michal said:
I know how you feel but at this point it seems that her responding to you would be a success.

I'm not sure what you mean by this line. Do you mean it is a better strategy to do nothing, or that if she replies to a message at all it would be a surprise? Thanks for clarifying. I appreciate the advice.
 

Michal

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Jul 5, 2013
Messages
278
Samson84 said:
I'm not sure what you mean by this line. Do you mean it is a better strategy to do nothing, or that if she replies to a message at all it would be a surprise? Thanks for clarifying. I appreciate the advice.
I did not word it in a best way. Maybe my read on your intentions is wrong but it seemed to me that even if she responded, you would think about that as a success from the emotional perspective. What I mean is that you would feel better just because she actually responded. I understand you want her back but the message you wanted to send kind of reminded me my past attempts and I remember having this warm feeling that she responded to me, that I had her attention. But then I read the message which was just some polite thing and I realized I had different expectations. And to me, this seems to be the case for you, that you are too invested in this and even a small reaction from her would mean a lot to you.
But again, my read is just based on the message you wanted to send.
 

Samson84

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Messages
78
Yes, Michal. You're probably right. I miss her, and it hurts not knowing why she stopped speaking to me .. if something I said offended her, or if she just forgot about me, or what. She really had the sweetest smile. I feel that I'm grieving for her.

I've talked to some other women and arranged dates but I almost feel guilty. And I don't like them half as much.
 

dcman

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Apr 3, 2017
Messages
96
Hi Samson,

You have taken time and willingness to look at suggestions from forum members in this group and also taken time to read and do your research. I am optimistic that you will arrive at the conclusion that will be in your best interest. I am going to give my opinions based on what you have written.

With regards to getting the girl back

Based on what you have written She seems to be in the idealization phase of the relationship with this new guy. I do not think there is much you can do currently to reignite her sexual interest. Only when things start going bad she will start looking out for other options. she seems to be an avid facebook user so you will see things unfold once the idealization phase is over with the new guy.

Meeting other girls

talked to my therapist again, and she said that BPD or no, what happened to me is a "mindfuck"
I believe your therapist probably mentioned the reasons why you need not feel guilty about this girl.So I am going to just mention why you should be having fun meeting new girls. From what you have written the main and only compatibility you have mentioned with this girl is sexual compatibility . Sexual compatibility while important is not unique and can be replicated. Is there a reason you are placing sexuality compatibility on a premium? Did you have compatibility in this area in your prior relationships?

Below is the description of both of you . Other than sexual and interest in fitness what else are common interests?
I'm 43 years old, British, handsome (apparently), athletic/muscular build, successful career, financially stable, well educated, intelligent, creative, charismatic, competitive powerlifter, pianist. Divorcing after 24-year marriage, live alone in UK city apartment. She's 27, from USA midwest, single mum, fitness model, competitive bodybuilder, used to negative military guys and liked my confident affirming British gentleman approach. She's had two marriages: the first to a violent abuser, the second that was over in weeks bc he had been cheating on her throughout.

Based on what you have mentioned about yourself there are girls that can offer you sexual compatibility as well common interest in areas like stability, creativity, music, family, traveling and so on. It will come with the added benefit of not needing to deal with the BPD traits . Instead of putting pressure on yourself with a goal in mind in meeting new girls just think meeting other women as an opportunity to get to know a new person. If there are many things in common and you have fun together great otherwise move on .
 

dcman

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Apr 3, 2017
Messages
96
Dear Samson,

I wanted to share more of my experience as feel it would better explain what I wrote earlier. With The girl with BPD traits I was with we ended up breaking up a couple of times but ended up getting back together within a couple of weeks. In the third occasion, we broke up she just completely disappeared she blocked me in face book, skype whats app and Was not communicating to me. I tried emailing, talking to her friends, cards, sent flowers and did all I could think to get back with her. A month later through social media that I realized she was with another man. When I finally connected on the phone with her she made me feel I was responsible for treating her well when she was with me but after seeing her with another man was the reason I was acting this way now. I was not serious with her and all other stuff to make me guilty. It was too late as she has already made up her mind and moved on. She was not willing to take calls or talk to me further. I had been with several break ups and none of them took more than a few weeks to recover. In this case I was ridden with guilt, confusion and did not understand what had happened. When I was looking in the web for ways to get over a break up I came across Scot Drexler’s article. I had been with her for a while so I had a good history of her life ex boy friends, Family, friends, work and so on. It made it seem that she had BPD traits. I was still missing her and wanted to get back even if she had BPD or not. I felt with all that I know that I could handle her if given another opportunity. As she was not picking up my phones I purchased a pre-paid SIM card with a different number and finally reached her. I asked her if we could at least meet. But she was unwilling and made me feel further bad by describing her new life. She went all out of her way to make me feel bad. It was at this point something snapped in me and I hung up. I could not stand the hurt and humiliation any more longer. I realized how I had changed from a confident, optimistic, creative, sociable man to something that I could not recognize myself. Whether BPD or Not I decided I was going to certainly move on.

Initially it was tough, as I felt that none of the others I meet were connecting to me at her level. Later I realized while all women have a phase where they idolize the man the with the BPD’s it is more at an extreme level. This was the reason I could not feel others were matching to her level. If I had just racked up numbers it would have made my recovery faster. I was still not sure if she had bpd or if my poor relationship skills were the reason for the relationship to end. After 4 months since my last contact with her, she un blocked me on social media. I could see there were no longer pictures of the new guy. She was responding to the emails I have written months before but were angry messages laying the guilt on me. I decided not to respond to avoid losing the progress I had made. She then changed the covered picture of her social media page to a sensual photo with a necklace I had given her. In a moment of weakness, I thought what harm would come in at least responding to her messages. I responded to her messages and she insisted on meeting immediately. Even though I knew it was a bad idea I decided to meet her the same night. When we meet after a few minutes of exchanging pleasantries she again decided to say how I had hurt her when she was with me and how she wasted her time. I came to the realization I could not have anything normal with her, so I told her that I am not going to be disrespected in this manner any more longer and would be leaving. She could not believe I would leave after months of trying to get back with her. I paid the bill and left. She sent some very nasty messages on whtsapp but I did not respond. One of her friends probably after two weeks since I last meet her contacted me. She asked me if she had returned back with me. The new guy she had been with after me had asked this friend to find out. He had been discarded in the same manner and he was trying to find her whereabouts. The patterns this girl followed was more or less the same. It was at this point, I could finally say with certainty she had BPD.

I consider myself lucky for coming across Scot Drexler’s article as without it I would not be where I am currently with my life. I started screening woman better and got the opportunity to be with some extremely wonderful woman. I had the stability back to pursue my goals and return to my original self.
 

Samson84

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Messages
78
Dear dcman,

Thank you very much for your earlier reply, and for this honest sharing of your own traumatic experience with your ex. It must have been a very painful time for you.

I think I am learning from my experiences that normal pain associated with loss of a relationship is greatly compounded when we are led to believe we acted 'wrong' or 'bad' and that the loss is our fault. For me I think this leads to confusion and depression. This happened in a huge way when my marriage ended after 24 years, as well as to a small extent with this latest relationship we have discussed.

I have been considering your previous reply in the past days and I very much appreciate and respect the way you have brought some good perspective for me. Thanks in part to this, I have stopped blaming myself for the way things turned out and recognized there were a lot of limitations in the situation, and that is (a) not all about my mistakes, and (b) not about me being 'not good enough'. As a result, I feel a lot lighter, although still sad at times.

I also did a 'relationship survey' which allows you to score each of 8 different areas of relationship health, to really assess the quality of your relationship with someone. This is usually done for couples to see in what areas they want to improve their relationship. I did it on my own with reference to my ex-wife, and with my ex-not-quite-gf. This was sobering as I realized that my marriage was extremely toxic by the end. I also realized that there were quite a few aspects that would have scored fairly low for a relationship with this other woman too.

I think I have a lot going for me both in terms of life success, charisma, but also in terms of these relationship skills. So I finally reach the point where I think, I deserve better than to be treated in this way. One of the things I read about people with BPD is that they tend to pick relationship partners who are very giving and understanding. Initially I thought this says something bad about me, like that I am 'weak' or 'beta'. But now I think that thoughtfulness, empathy, generosity are actually assets in a relationship and as long as I don't let myself be taken advantage of, these are actually strengths in my favour as a guy.

I feel I have finally been able to let go to the point of thinking, oh well, that was sexy but kinda weird, and just wishing her well and if she is happy then good, and if we do or don't see each other again, that's ok with me.

I definitely need to get out there and meet and date some more women though! Not getting any younger!
 

Samson84

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Messages
78
Quick update to this situation, for anyone who finds the thread relevant.

It's been about 4 months now since this woman (who may have BPD traits) ditched me for another guy, and about 3 months since we had any contact.

There's been a lot for me to learn through this situation, about myself, and about attraction and relationships. It's been tough. I still think her about her every day, although when I catch myself, I can move my mind onto something else.

A few weeks ago, I thought I was feeling better, and I felt safe to look through some photos and just see it as positive memories. But I ended up looking on her bf's facebook page, and seeing photos of the two of them goofing around together and she was smiling and looked sooo happy. Then I got really upset and I didn't even know why. They were both commenting on the photo like, "I am so in love with you," and "I love you so much too," (not that he can spell correctly though -- bitter lol). That was from about 2 months ago, when they had been together about 2 months.

It brings up a lot of questions for me, like, what does falling in love look like in a healthy relationship? Is it possible that two healthy people would be like this? Or is this more of a love-bombing situation? If this is a BPD/codependent situation, how come they are still together and both feeling so happy? Will I ever know whether I dodged a bullet or lost my dream woman? Why have I never met anyone else I felt so passionate for? And why didn't I upgrade her to gf status when I had the chance? What was holding me back, what it fear of intimacy or genuine caution? Will she ever reach out to me again, and if she does, how will I respond? Why do I feel so dependent on the affections of this particular person? Since I 'lost' to this other guy, does that mean I'm less attractive, less dominant?

These are questions that I'm working through, to grow and avoid making the same mistakes in future.

At the same time, I've been working on myself - career, home, gym, and chatting to women when I get the chance. I'm pretty much resigned to being single for quite a while.
 

Seppuku

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
1,149
The previous exchanges here had a feel of "it's not my fault, it's because she's BPD". I don't know if she's BPD or not, but in any case, you did some gaming mistakes. Here is what I perceived from your original write-up:

1. You can't say "we cannot be a couple because of the distance thing". You did shut the door by saying this. All doors should always remain open because you simply do not know about tomorrow.
2. Your emotional breakdown. It's a turnoff for women.
3. Inconsistent behavior. Lover at the beginning - which is displaying strength. Then distressed - which is displaying weakness. It's what is called here "lack of congruence".
4. The last two points are coming from a place of neediness. It is another turnoff.

And I'm not pointing this to make you feel bad. It's precisely so that you avoid doing this again in the future. It's much better to focus on what you did wrong - and can possibly improve - than on external circumstances which are out of your control (i.e. "she's BPD"). Besides, now you discover that she doesn't look so BPD in her FB exchange... So now what?

Since I 'lost' to this other guy, does that mean I'm less attractive, less dominant?
It means he had better game than you had - that's all. It is all fixable, provided that you are looking at what you do with a critical eye and are proactive to improve - and take the lessons home.

So next time you find a woman you like:
* Don't say anything that may close a door
* Let her worry about being a couple and in a relationship. It's her realm! Let her chase for it!
* Avoid unnecessary display of negative emotions
* Avoid display of neediness. "Uber-cool" is the name of the game!

Another point now. You say she "ditched you for another guy". Could it be that the guy was in the picture before you? That you were the outsider from the beginning? That she was, in fact, only looking for a "summer fling" with no strings attached. Or that she let herself carry away by the romance of the situation, then returned to her "former self" when she got back home? So-called "good girls" do that, too.

Seppuku
 

Samson84

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Messages
78
Thanks Seppuku, yeah I got it. I realize I made mistakes. But I didn't know what I didn't know. And when you lose someone special it's like you're grieving. It hurts, that's all. She's like the second woman I "fell for" in my life. And I'm still trying to forgive myself.

Whether it is 'all fixable' is a matter of perspective. I'm sure my gaming mistakes are all fixable, and that could help me in the future with other potential partners. But in this particular situation it doesn't help me. And since each person is unique, that can be a tough pill to swallow when you care about a person. I'm sure you must have also lost someone you had grown to feel deeply for.

Anyway, as always, I appreciate the tips, thank you.
 

Seppuku

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
1,149
You're welcome. Well, this forum is normally for guys who are willing to analyze what they are doing, in order to improve - it is action oriented rather than emotion oriented. I'm afraid I will be of poor help on the emotional side. Please take all advice here with a constructive mind.

Yes, it is all fixable - for the benefit of future girls only. Usually when we make (big) mistakes with a girl we rarely get a second chance - sorry to say.

However, when you are more experienced and do things better (i.e. no fuck up) you will be pleased to see "returning girls" - they had disappeared for some time, then reappear again after maybe 6 or 12 months or so. It means that if you have seduced about 50 girls or more, you constantly have a stream of past girls coming back. Between the current girls, and the returning girls, you almost have no need for getting new girls - LOL. It's tricky, because you fall into laziness.

Seppuku
 

Inowtakethelead

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Sep 24, 2017
Messages
50
Seppuku said:
The previous exchanges here had a feel of "it's not my fault, it's because she's BPD". I don't know if she's BPD or not, but in any case, you did some gaming mistakes. Here is what I perceived from your original write-up:

1. You can't say "we cannot be a couple because of the distance thing". You did shut the door by saying this. All doors should always remain open because you simply do not know about tomorrow.
2. Your emotional breakdown. It's a turnoff for women.
3. Inconsistent behavior. Lover at the beginning - which is displaying strength. Then distressed - which is displaying weakness. It's what is called here "lack of congruence".
4. The last two points are coming from a place of neediness. It is another turnoff.

And I'm not pointing this to make you feel bad. It's precisely so that you avoid doing this again in the future. It's much better to focus on what you did wrong - and can possibly improve - than on external circumstances which are out of your control (i.e. "she's BPD"). Besides, now you discover that she doesn't look so BPD in her FB exchange... So now what?

Since I 'lost' to this other guy, does that mean I'm less attractive, less dominant?
It means he had better game than you had - that's all. It is all fixable, provided that you are looking at what you do with a critical eye and are proactive to improve - and take the lessons home.

So next time you find a woman you like:
* Don't say anything that may close a door
* Let her worry about being a couple and in a relationship. It's her realm! Let her chase for it!
* Avoid unnecessary display of negative emotions
* Avoid display of neediness. "Uber-cool" is the name of the game!

Another point now. You say she "ditched you for another guy". Could it be that the guy was in the picture before you? That you were the outsider from the beginning? That she was, in fact, only looking for a "summer fling" with no strings attached. Or that she let herself carry away by the romance of the situation, then returned to her "former self" when she got back home? So-called "good girls" do that, too.

Seppuku


Thabk you saved in notes.
 

dcman

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Apr 3, 2017
Messages
96
Hi Samson, I Just had a chance to read your update and had a couple of observations to highlight.

Why do I feel so dependent on the affections of this particular person?
I had the same issue when I broke up. Being in a new city where I hardly knew people made it more difficult to forget and move on initially. Building up my social life really played a major role to overcome this feeling. I got a work out buddy to go to the gyms, went to meetup groups, couch surfing meetings on Thursday, have wings to go out on the weekends and so allowed me not to be fixated helped the recovery from the break up. These days my interactions, relation with a woman are just a part of my life and not depended on the interactions with them go. It has made woman see me as high value, get needed social proof and also, I get to meet women with more common interests through social contacts. Wanted to share this with you.

At the same time, I've been working on myself - career, home, gym, and chatting to women when I get the chance
While chatting with woman is a good start. Try to make your interactions with woman more than just a chat. I am quoting below how you felt after a five-minute interaction with a woman that you interacted at the gym

Later she came up to me on her own when she had finished training and we talked for maybe 5 minutes. I was asking her about her sport and letting her talk. I tried not to gawp and keep my composure even though she is extremely beautiful and has an incredible body. I showed that I was really interested in what she was telling me and that I could relate to her dedication. I really am genuinely fascinated to hear about her story, even if she's not interested in a date.

Provide this effect in reverse where any girl that interacts with you feel fascinated and wants to keep continuing the conversation and feels you are of high value. This gives you the opportunity to do a venue change, number close, isolate what you feel like doing. You are good with words and your writing is flowered with details use them to build the needed rapport. I wanted to high light this as I felt it may be an area that could help with getting a woman for the long term with more interests in common.

I realize I made mistakes. But I didn't know what I didn't know. And when you lose someone special it's like you're grieving. It hurts, that's all. She's like the second woman I "fell for" in my life. And I'm still trying to forgive myself.

Interactions, seduction, relation with a woman is not going to be always mistake free. One of the reasons I feel relaxed and ease with woman is I have learnt now not to beat myself over mistakes. With experience, I have learnt to limit mistakes and how to recover from them or move on if needed. More the interests are in common with a woman the easier is the interaction and relationship is going to be from personal experience.
 
Top