What's new

The Game Of Relationships Is Won In The Nuances

PaulieFlyn10

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Mar 2, 2022
Messages
257
This will be a LONG thread. And for reasons you're about to find out.

In this thread, my goal was to give a future perspective as to where the seduction/manospher/pick up community is headed. More and more guys will look more for relationships than pick up. In the last 4 years, I've seen more guys in my social circle fall into relationships more than ever. This shift creates an opportunity, not just in marketing and coaching but in how guys see relationships.

The thing with relationships is that it is EXTREMELY nuanced and time consuming. This thread is to give guys a heads up on what to expect. These are from my experiences, those of guys around me, and from GC. If you've been in relationships 4 years and above, your opinions will be highly valued. (@POB @Skills ). If you havent but you have something interesting to say then by all means do so.

Before i get into some of the nuances, let's look at possible reasons why many guys are falling into relationships


WHY ARE MORE GUYS GETTING INTO RELATIONSHIPS

Many reasons can be attributed to this. But I've boiled things down to three things: 1) Guys getting older and wanting to leave the pick up lifestyle. Pretty self explanatory. As guys get older, the urge to calm things down a bit increases. 2) Guys wanting to be around women they actually like. Most guys have a type. And are more eager to have FBs, GFs & Wives that fit into their preferred archetype and taste. I've had many guys complain how they can't stand being around girls they don't like even if they're fucking them. 3) Guys unknowingly falling for Gf frames. Lots of guys are unaware how girls set frames very early and in subtle ways that positions the vibe towards relationships. This article by @Chase is a good primer into this. And then this by Drexel scott



NUANCES! NUANCES!!

This will be an extensive list on various pitfalls, situations, obstacles etc many men face in relationships. Some will simply be me asking questions on them as a way to draw attention. While others will be me giving commentary and offering my perspective.



>>>>> The 2 Year Drop

When it comes to relationships, very few concepts are as accurate as this. Chase wrote about it here. In summary, the 2 year drop is a concept that feelings and emotions tend to fade within two years. And it came as no surprise when ALL but one of the relationships in my social circle end ed within 2 years. In fact, this is so common, it should be talked about more. Most guys are completely clueless and will often blame a host of things as to why these things happen

So my question, what are your best ways to maintain that spark and mitigate the 2 year drop. And what are the biggest reasons that cause the 2 year drop to happen(from a more nuanced and practical perspective)


>>>>>> Jealousy Games 1 (When you are both out together)

By far the biggest nuanced challenges men face in relationships is around jealousy. When guys meet me for advice jealousy is a recurring issue. This first type is when you guys are both out together. She's either talking with an uber driver, talking with a waiter. Let's say she runs into an old male friend or even an ex.' Or even guys trying hit on her or flirt with her. Take note, this girl is ALREADY your main girl.

How do you respond? Act unaffected at all times? Or call it out? I was watching a red pill video where the guy shared an experience with his gf. They were having dinner and she was checking out a guy. He then told her "You can go join him if you want'' Do you agree with an approach like that or would you handle things differently.

Also, do these jealousy games ever stop? My belief is that they don't. But I read an article on Gc that talked about how you can remove jealousy games from your woman. But I reckon if she's hot, these games never stop. Maybe they reduce but never truly go away. what do you think?


>>>>>> Jealousy Games 2 (When She's Out by herself)

If you date a hot woman, guaranteed guys will hit on her when you're not around. This particular scenario came from his now ex. During their relationship, she went for a wedding. And of course, guys were flirting and talking with her. Of course, she's not a fool and knows what's up. She told him about her experience (probably in a bid to make him jealous too) and while she was talking he was waiting for the moment she told those guys "I have a boyfriend" That moment never came. She didnt tell them. And he got offended and made a big deal out of it.

She then proceeded to defend herself saying she was talking to them to learn new things and the whole bf thing might scare them of.

So my question, what is acceptable behaviour for when you're not present. Should she give out numbers? Is her not mentioning her bf an issue? MANY guys i've talked to see giving out numbers, entertaining guys especially without mentioning she has a bf as unacceptable. What are your thoughts



>>>>>> Influence OF friends & Family

How big of an influence is family and friends? and how would you handle situations where her friends are clearly bad for her and the relationship. For example, she having friends that are huge party girls or serial cheaters. Or she having friends that give her bad advice or probably dont like you


>>>>>> Giving Money To Your Woman

What's your take on giving your woman an agreed amount of money every month. Either as a housewife or workwife


>>>>>> Life Goals

How do you handle changes in life goals either from your end or hers


>>>>>Behavioral shaping

What frames and behaviours do you shape or create to make a woman more devoted/loyal. And HOW do you typically do this


>>>>> When she says "No sex"

Top 3 complaint i get from my married friends: 'my wife has changed. We barely have sex any more" How would you handle a situation where your girl or wife denies sex. and what do you think are the main causes of this.



>>>> Living Together

What are your best advice/tips for couples living together? potential issues? etc


>>>> Her Boss Vs You

Your girl or wife used to stay at home. But now she has a career and wants to start work. How do you handle situations where what you want her to do goes against what her boss wants. Say for example, you want her early by 4 and the boss wants her to work a bit late to meet certain quotas. How do you maintain your stance? or are their instances where it's okay for her to do what the boss says.

Another variation, how do you handle issues of sexual advances from your girl's superiors. Either when she brings them up to you or when you notice them. Also, if she never brings them up to you but you happen to find out, do you hold it against her as a fault



>>>>> Single Girl Behaviour

In this great article @Karea Ricardus D. talks about single girl behaviours girls might do while in a relationship. One of which is having really close guy friends, sleeping over at a guy's house. i Have seen SO MANY guys with these issues. Now, we'll assume nothing happened. But these are just some of the few i've seen:


gf goes out with a male friend then sleeps in his house but a different room. gf surrounds herself with guy friends and goes out with them. gf goes out partying etc

How do you get her to stop behaviours like these and other variations. Also how do you handle her pushbacks like: "nothing will happen. you're being insecure" OR "I've known these guys before you. I can't just cut them off"

Another thing, at what point/stage in the relationship is it right to get her to limit or completely cut off male friendships or other single girl behaviours



>>>>> Her Ex Reaching Out

One of my friends is in talking stages with a new girl. She told him her ex that left her reached out to her and wants to get back. He's apologizing and letting her know that he's changed.

In his previous relationship, he told his gf to block him and she made excuses for the ex. Now, i told him that he should tell he wont force her or tell what to do as they're both adults but he should also subtly let her know he doesnt take girls seriously that keep in contact with their exes. What do you think about it? And how do you respond when she attempts to manipulate you when you havent reached out in a while: "You're using what i told you about my ex to avoid me"

How would you handle such situations.


>>>>> Ignorance or Malice??

In this movie scene, Sonny's advice is funny and eye opening. Basically he tells a kid about a door test: If you open the door for a woman to get in and she doesn't reach over to your door and lift up the button so you can get in then you dump her cause she's selfish.

In today's world different men and cultures have their own versions of the door test. Certain things they just look and observe to know if a girl is a candidate for a LTR. However i've noticed a lot of young girls are socially akward & inexperienced. I've had girls search for things like: How do you know a guy likes you OR "what does it mean when he says this

So my question is, in a situation she fails your own version of a door test how do you decided it's simply her being ignorant or she's actually a walking red flag


>>>>> Speed of sex

One of by biggest motivations for fast sex was that in one of Chase oldest articles he mentioned that a girl fucking you fast (first date, SDL) most times meant she really liked you and would mean your relationship would be better.

However, in recent years, he changed his stance on that. To him, he has seen good relationships even when the sex didnt happen fast. Because of this, fast sex while still important isnt such a big factor as he initially thought


what are your thoughts?


>>>>>Contact her every day??

How often is required to call or text an LTR


>>>>> Ï need space


when you hear this either in a relationship, what caused this and how would you typically respond



So yeah, these are few nuanced situations ive noticed come up in various relationships. Thanks for reading this far
 

Adventurer

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Nov 28, 2022
Messages
144
Kj because I never had a long relationship but I'm also interested in those topics

My understanding is that she has to know you can replace her at any moment and use it as deterrent to prevent any bullshit, until you have kids with her and she has something else to do than stir up drama

I'm JM from Discord btw, we talked there
 
you miss 100% of the shots you don't take

Chase

Chieftan
Staff member
tribal-elder
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,079
@PaulieFlyn10,

Neat post! I'll respond to some of these. Will try to be brief; you have many questions here.

In this thread, my goal was to give a future perspective as to where the seduction/manospher/pick up community is headed. More and more guys will look more for relationships than pick up. In the last 4 years, I've seen more guys in my social circle fall into relationships more than ever. This shift creates an opportunity, not just in marketing and coaching but in how guys see relationships.

Part of this is age. No matter what generation of seducers you are in, your friends/generation is going to progressively settle down as they age. The perception will be that "everyone is getting into committed relationships / getting married / starting families." Every generation goes through this though.

The real question (that is still unclear to me) is, "Do 20-something men today want committed relationships more than they did when I was a 20-something?"

So my question, what are your best ways to maintain that spark and mitigate the 2 year drop. And what are the biggest reasons that cause the 2 year drop to happen(from a more nuanced and practical perspective)

There are personality differences between girls. Also, younger girls will sometimes be fine to hang around longer than 2 years because they're under less time pressure. Girls who feel VERY strongly that their guy is "on the cusp" and may be willing to commit with a bit more time can push things out to 3 or sometimes 4 years. You can extend things by moving in (often extends the 2 years to 4 years) or getting engaged (similar 2-year extension).

Marriage without babies offers a variable extension, depending on how badly the girl wants to reproduce. Anywhere from a 2- to 5-year extension without children.

Having a baby together is the "lifetime extension."

Any of these can be blown up by the guy dramatically changing (becomes depressed, long-term unemployed) or dramatically reducing his investment in the relationship (starts cheating with abandon and neglecting the woman). At that point "extensions" are irrelevant.

>>>>>> Jealousy Games 1 (When you are both out together)

By far the biggest nuanced challenges men face in relationships is around jealousy. When guys meet me for advice jealousy is a recurring issue. This first type is when you guys are both out together. She's either talking with an uber driver, talking with a waiter. Let's say she runs into an old male friend or even an ex.' Or even guys trying hit on her or flirt with her. Take note, this girl is ALREADY your main girl.

How do you respond? Act unaffected at all times? Or call it out? I was watching a red pill video where the guy shared an experience with his gf. They were having dinner and she was checking out a guy. He then told her "You can go join him if you want'' Do you agree with an approach like that or would you handle things differently.

Depends. Are you with a girl who actively tries to make you jealous? Or is she just polite with these guys? You need to treat those two very differently.

I will playfully joke with girls when they check out other guys or comment on them, personally. e.g., if a chick I am with is like, "Wow, that guy is very handsome! And rich, too! Wow, he's perfect!"

I will just be like, "Finally, we've found someone who can take you off my hands!"

Of course that is with a healthy relationship dynamic where I know she is joking around and she knows I am joking around.

In a fucked up relationship dynamic the chick may escalate and respond to you making a remark like this by going over to flirt with the guy & really try to bring out your jealous rage. IMO you simply should not be with this kind of woman or in this kind of fucked up relationship at all... but many guys are.

Also, do these jealousy games ever stop? My belief is that they don't.

Nah. But if the dynamic is healthy they are just little tests, like anything.

>>>>>> Jealousy Games 2 (When She's Out by herself)

If you date a hot woman, guaranteed guys will hit on her when you're not around. This particular scenario came from his now ex. During their relationship, she went for a wedding. And of course, guys were flirting and talking with her. Of course, she's not a fool and knows what's up. She told him about her experience (probably in a bid to make him jealous too) and while she was talking he was waiting for the moment she told those guys "I have a boyfriend" That moment never came. She didnt tell them. And he got offended and made a big deal out of it.

She then proceeded to defend herself saying she was talking to them to learn new things and the whole bf thing might scare them of.

So my question, what is acceptable behaviour for when you're not present. Should she give out numbers? Is her not mentioning her bf an issue? MANY guys i've talked to see giving out numbers, entertaining guys especially without mentioning she has a bf as unacceptable. What are your thoughts

If the relationship is healthy she will typically tell you about any substantial interactions she had.

You can just nod knowingly or give a basic response ("Sounds like you were Miss Popular today!" if she had a couple of dudes hit on her, for instance).

She doesn't need to mention having a boyfriend unless guys are being pushy or not taking hints. "I have a boyfriend" is the defense for guys who aren't following her cues.

As for giving out her number... sometimes young/dumb chicks do this just to get guys away.

You may need to train them to not give out their numbers if you don't want a bunch of random dudes hitting on them trying to get in their pants.

Also: the less stable the relationship is for her, the more likely she is to want to cultivate backup options. So to some extent this will depend on relationship stability.

>>>>>> Influence OF friends & Family

How big of an influence is family and friends? and how would you handle situations where her friends are clearly bad for her and the relationship. For example, she having friends that are huge party girls or serial cheaters. Or she having friends that give her bad advice or probably dont like you

Slut friends are a pretty big dealbreaker for me.

It's not an absolute. I have known girls who stayed loyal to their guys despite slut friends constantly pushing them to cheat.

But it is an added wildcard you really do not need in a relationship.

A girl who is committed and not a slut will typically distance herself from slut friends as the relationship progresses.

If she does not, you should take that as a sign that she is more aligned with them than you thought.

>>>>>> Giving Money To Your Woman

What's your take on giving your woman an agreed amount of money every month. Either as a housewife or workwife

Yeah, if she's a housewife set up an account and put a certain amount of money in it based on however many expenses she's managing.

I assume you're using 'workwife' to mean 'wife who had a job' (and not what the word actually means, which is 'woman you work with whom you are close to / flirt with, but who is not your girlfriend or wife'). If she's working, just have a joint account you both contribute to and pay bills from.

If she's working, her disposable income comes from her job.

>>>>>> Life Goals

How do you handle changes in life goals either from your end or hers

What's the change?

>>>>>Behavioral shaping

What frames and behaviours do you shape or create to make a woman more devoted/loyal. And HOW do you typically do this

Politeness. Manners. Compliance. Orderliness. Preparing certain things for you the way you like them. Sexual initiative. Exercise. Staying in shape. Dressing well / grooming.

Tell her what you want. Use operant conditioning to reinforce.

>>>>> When she says "No sex"

Top 3 complaint i get from my married friends: 'my wife has changed. We barely have sex any more" How would you handle a situation where your girl or wife denies sex. and what do you think are the main causes of this.


>>>> Living Together

What are your best advice/tips for couples living together? potential issues? etc

Make sure you have a space that is your space (den, office, etc.).

She is still going to try to invade it as much as possible, so you are just going to need to enforce the borders like she's an illegal Mexican trying to swim across the Rio Grande.

Figure out if one or both of you is a "needs space to cool down" type. If so, the other or both need to learn to respect that when things get heated, otherwise everything just keeps escalating.

Having separate bedrooms helps with sex life IMO. Every time she sneaks over to yours it's more exciting for her. Sleeping in the same bed with you nightly is less of a 'routine'.

If one of you is a lot messier than the other you are going to have fights and annoyances over that. You will have to figure out how to deal with it.

>>>> Her Boss Vs You

Your girl or wife used to stay at home. But now she has a career and wants to start work. How do you handle situations where what you want her to do goes against what her boss wants. Say for example, you want her early by 4 and the boss wants her to work a bit late to meet certain quotas. How do you maintain your stance? or are their instances where it's okay for her to do what the boss says.

Another variation, how do you handle issues of sexual advances from your girl's superiors. Either when she brings them up to you or when you notice them. Also, if she never brings them up to you but you happen to find out, do you hold it against her as a fault

Better IMO to help her start her own business or get her doing something where she's more independent.

Real estate agent, freelance graphic designer, etc.

Once she has a job the job owns her time. You just get her when she's free.

Never had a gal deal with advances from a superior while I was with her so I can't say for sure there. Guess it depends whether she knows how to handle it, how aggressive/persistent the dude is, etc.

I had a GF who told me about her time as a university instructor when her boss brought her into this office and put the moves on her. She slapped him off her then threatened to report him to the university. He begged her not to; she stated her terms to not report him and spent the rest of her time at the university collecting her full salary without having to do any more teaching, lol.

>>>>> Single Girl Behaviour

In this great article @Karea Ricardus D. talks about single girl behaviours girls might do while in a relationship. One of which is having really close guy friends, sleeping over at a guy's house. i Have seen SO MANY guys with these issues. Now, we'll assume nothing happened. But these are just some of the few i've seen:


gf goes out with a male friend then sleeps in his house but a different room. gf surrounds herself with guy friends and goes out with them. gf goes out partying etc

How do you get her to stop behaviours like these and other variations. Also how do you handle her pushbacks like: "nothing will happen. you're being insecure" OR "I've known these guys before you. I can't just cut them off"

Another thing, at what point/stage in the relationship is it right to get her to limit or completely cut off male friendships or other single girl behaviours

What level of relationship?

Girls will keep orbiters around when it's early/unstable.

Here's the simplest way I have found to get her to knock it off:

YOU: Oh, I see, you're going out with that guy. That's cool. I'll probably just call XYZ girl and see if she wants to do something.

GIRL: ????!!! What no!!! Don't go out with her! What if you cheat!

YOU: What do you mean? You're going with him. I'm just going to go with her.

GIRL: But that's different! You're a guy!

YOU: What is that guy you're going out with? Has he had his balls removed?

GIRL: No but you're you!

YOU: Men are all the same.

As soon as you call their bluff and are going to start bringing girls in and doing the same stuff with girls that they are doing with guys, if they want to keep you they stop it super quick.

>>>>> Her Ex Reaching Out

One of my friends is in talking stages with a new girl. She told him her ex that left her reached out to her and wants to get back. He's apologizing and letting her know that he's changed.

I had a chick tell me about this once.

Exact same situation. Fiancé cheated on her, they broke up, 4 years later he reached out apologizing saying he felt so bad and asking where she was in life and if she's gotten married yet.

I was just like "Seems like his other options haven't worked out and he's decided you're the best he's going to get."

We were on-again, off-again and she mulled responding to him. Actually asked me what she should do.

I was like, "I dunno. Sounds like he's settling for you. I'd rather just find someone else personally. But do whatever you want to do."

She ended up not responding to him (and in the end married a really great guy. Great match for her).

In his previous relationship, he told his gf to block him and she made excuses for the ex. Now, i told him that he should tell he wont force her or tell what to do as they're both adults but he should also subtly let her know he doesnt take girls seriously that keep in contact with their exes. What do you think about it?

Sounds good to me.

And how do you respond when she attempts to manipulate you when you havent reached out in a while: "You're using what i told you about my ex to avoid me"

How would you handle such situations.

Why did the guy not reach out for a while? Had they broken up or something?

>>>>> Ignorance or Malice??

In this movie scene, Sonny's advice is funny and eye opening. Basically he tells a kid about a door test: If you open the door for a woman to get in and she doesn't reach over to your door and lift up the button so you can get in then you dump her cause she's selfish.

In today's world different men and cultures have their own versions of the door test. Certain things they just look and observe to know if a girl is a candidate for a LTR. However i've noticed a lot of young girls are socially akward & inexperienced. I've had girls search for things like: How do you know a guy likes you OR "what does it mean when he says this

So my question is, in a situation she fails your own version of a door test how do you decided it's simply her being ignorant or she's actually a walking red flag

Depends how old she is.

If you're going for older chicks, they should know etiquette more.

If she's young, just assume she's ignorant and train her.

Most women don't receive etiquette training in school or from their mothers or older sisters nowadays.

>>>>> Speed of sex

One of by biggest motivations for fast sex was that in one of Chase oldest articles he mentioned that a girl fucking you fast (first date, SDL) most times meant she really liked you and would mean your relationship would be better.

However, in recent years, he changed his stance on that. To him, he has seen good relationships even when the sex didnt happen fast. Because of this, fast sex while still important isnt such a big factor as he initially thought


what are your thoughts?

For anyone who hasn't read the article:


>>>>>Contact her every day??

How often is required to call or text an LTR

There's an argument that can be made for daily.

If you want to keep some distance it's better to have a few days off.

Of course don't be evasive if she contacts you first.

>>>>> Ï need space


when you hear this either in a relationship, what caused this and how would you typically respond

How much space are we talking here?

She needs a few hours to process what happened / what you talked about?

Or she wants a "break"?

If a few hours: she's just a personality type that needs calm and tranquility to process new ideas/perspectives. Give her her space, then talk when she's ready.

If she wants a multi-week break to go experience other dudes then decide if she would rather you or one of them:

Nah.

Tell her all sales are final.

She can have the break if she wants.

But after that if she wants the relationship, it will have to be with someone else.

So yeah, these are few nuanced situations ive noticed come up in various relationships. Thanks for reading this far

Again, good questions!

Chase
 
Top