Hey EP,
I'll give it a try. Mr Rob is welcome to step in with his own perspective as well.
1. - What's going through a girl's mind if she agrees to a date?
- Has she already decided she's DTF?
- Is she not planning on sex at all?
- Does she consciously really want sex to happen, but knows she will put up resistance/tests along the whole way?
I have had some girls telling me they were ready to follow me in bed, if it came to that, before our first date. BUT I would say the majority of them do not know beforehand. Most of the time I would say her wanting sex is not a conscious process, more something growing in the background without them being aware - at first. They really become aware they desire it when they turn on during the final escalation.
2. Can the date itself be incongruent?
- If I'm a cool, confident guy, why would I not just say let's meet for coffee -> meet, pay for, and pick up coffee -> then say "alright now let's head back to my/your place to drink this"?
The scenario you describe here would ring big ASD alarms in her head. It helps if you make a little bit of human connection. So it's more:
" let's meet for coffee -> meet, pay for, and pick up coffee -> sit down, make her talk about here and display genuine interest -> then say "alright now let's head back to my/your place to [INSERT EXCUSE HERE]"
3. Similarly, how is a date supposed to compete with tinder? If a beautiful girl wants sex, why would she not just hop on tinder, swipe for 5 minutes, then have her plans for the night?
No, because most of them don't consciously know what they want. Plus, it could be a date out of Tinder
- Isn't the date itself slotting you at least partially into the boyfriend category right off the bat?
I've been to over 130 first dates I think. Answer is clearly NO
if you run the date the right way. I assure you that if you take her from first meet ever in a coffee shop, to your bed, in less than two hours time, it will definitely not look like the boyfriend slot. However if you take her to a formal restaurant, and didn't make a move before date 3, you will definitely look like the BF candidate.
4. So should I just not even bother with the idea of warming a girl up to the idea of sex, and get her demonstrating some IOIs?
I would normally say yes. However we have to keep in mind that there is something you are doing incorrectly during the date, which turns her off. We have to keep in mind that something could very well uncalibrated game. So I would advise that, for the moment, you avoid "game", and only concentrate on genuinely listening to her story.
- Should I only focus on persisting?
- How do you do all this on a 30-60 minute coffee date if you're following the template? Seems like just trying to deep dive one or two things about her takes 30 minutes.
- At this rate, you need to start persisting from the get go, no? Especially if it's going to take 3 asks to finally get a yes. Or 3 touches before she finally (hopefully) reciprocates.
No you don't persist from the get go. You spend the whole 60 minutes (OK, maybe up to 90) making her talk, and listen to her story. Then you end the date and get her to follow you in your car and isolate her. Here is where you apply persistence if required. In the Tactics forum, I recently wrote a post "she likes you, she follows you". Take a look.
5. So what's the actual stop sign from a girl? I might pose this question on the General board later. A lot of this advice sounds to me like 'just keep going even if she's saying no or clearly not interested.' This is a mindset I'm definitely not comfortable with.
- Do I really have to ask her 3 times at EVERY step of the process and use that rule of thumb as a stop sign?
The thing is, you cannot know if it's a real NO unless you have persisted and persisted a few times to no avail. I wasn't comfortable with this, too, at the beginning, but it pays to go over your discomfort. Remember that this kind of persistence is hugely sexy to a woman.
6. Assuming for the sake of discussion that I'm not persisting enough at each step of the process, how is this supposed to be fun? I thought the process was supposed to be fun. It's not fun for me if every step of the process needs to be a high-pressure sales job.
- Isn't it more fun to find girls that actually want to follow your lead?
The whole process is extremely fun (for you and her)
when you are comfortable running it. You may have to try it a few times before getting comfortable. But at first it will go against your comfort zone.
7. Should I not be making an effort to get to know a girl on a date? Lately I've been working on setting a more selective mindset, to try and help me seem like more of a challenge. Also to help me automatically ask screening questions that actually matter to me and hopefully get the girl qualifying.
- Is this a wrong approach?
- Should I be thinking of the date as just Step 1 in the process of guaranteed first date sex?
- Is this what the girl is expecting too?
Before you become intimate with the girl, time is running against you. So if your "effort to get to know" the girl is taking too long (e.g. three dates) you run a high chance of hitting the wall before you get anywhere. On the other hand, once you became intimate with her, now you have plenty of time to get to know her. So I would spend the bulk of my 60 / 90 minutes focusing on listening to her story, and normally attempt to isolate on date 1. That's about the time you actually need to "get to know her".
Having a couple of screening questions is always a good thing, as you are showing her that you are not automatically sold to her. It is not essential to seduction though.
There is no such thing as "guaranteed first date sex".